Hemantayan – Part 2

26 September 2020

A tribute to Hemant Kumar on his 31st Remembrance Day (16 June 1920 – 26 September 1989) in his Birth Centenary year by guest author N Venkataraman

(N Venkataraman launched the Centenary Celebration of Hemant Kumar with his superb article Hemantayan Part 1 on his Birth Centenary, 16 June 2020. This gave a comprehensive overview of Hemant Kumar’s early life, his rise as a singer and composer of great repute in Hindi and Bengali films and non-film songs, up to 1960.

In this second and concluding part of his tribute, Venkatarmanji carries on his excellent work and covers his remaining career post-1960. The special aspect of this article is his focus on Hemant Kumar’s forays into production of films, which is not highlighted much as his heavenly voice left such a powerful impact. This aspect is also important because it became Hemant Kumar’s hubris, sucking him into deep financial troubles. But the multifarious talent that he was, he was able to come out of it as he had become an icon in Bengali music as a singer and composer. That became his main arena, where he was the Monarch.

This two-part tribute by Venkataramanji is the most comprehensive you can find on any blog. It is not only a chronicle of Hemant Kumar’s life and his professional achievements, it also provides insight into the ecosystem of Hindi and Bengali films of the era, his strength of character, simplicity and generosity and also his foibles, and his ups and downs. We are passionately fond of his singing and music direction, our awareness being primarily limited to Hindi. Thanks to Venkataramanji now we know that Hemant Kumar was much larger than that.  We can’t thank Venkataramanji enough for this. – AK)

Hemant Kumar 1It was now time to build up on this success and reputation. Was he able to consolidate his position and career in Bombay and also in Calcutta? I will leave that for another post, the second part of this write-up. I would be covering his career post-1960 in the second part of my article”.

I had concluded the first part, Hemantayan – Part1 with the above lines.

I would break up this part into two sections, Hemant Kumar’s career in Bombay/ Hindi films post 1960 and his career in Calcutta/ Bengali films during the same period. And his career in these two areas presents a contrasting scenario in every respect. Let me set the ball rolling with his stint in Bombay. First let me do a quick recap.

After the resounding success of ‘Nagin’ (1954) he was flooded with offers. And responding to the overwhelming offers, Hemant Kumar scored music for thirty films between the years 1955 and 1960. A year-wise overview would give us a clearer picture.

1955:  4 films – Bandish, Lagan, Bhagawat Mahima and Bahu
1956:  9 films – Hamara Watan, Laalten, Bandhan, Anjaan, Arab Ka Saudagar, Taaj, Inspector, Ek Hi Raasta   and Durgeshnandini
1957: 9 films – Kitna Badal Gaya Insaan, Bandhi, Champakali, Hill Station, Ek Jhalak, Payal, Yehudi Ki Ladki, Fashion and Miss Mary
1958: 3 films – Police, Sahar and Do Mastane
1959: 2 films – Hum Bhi Insaan Hain and Chaand
1960: 3 films – Duniya Jhukti Hai, Masoom and Girl Friend

Besides, he scored music for 20 Bengali films and 2 other regional language films (Marathi & Tamil).It is quite clear that he had taken up a huge workload. Also, he had to do a lot of travelling between Bombay, Calcutta and Madras. No doubt, his earnings from these films must have helped him to pay off his debts and by the end of the decade his commitment to his family at Calcutta and his extended family at Bombay would have eased to a great extent. At the same time it is very much evident that his number of films in Bombay declined. By the end of the sixties his number of songs as a playback singer for other music directors reflected a similar trend. At this juncture he ventured into production. In the next section I would cover Hemant Kumar’s career in Bombay/ Hindi films with emphasis on his production endeavours. I would delve deep into this dimension, since it had had a significant impact on his life and career. Since all his production ventures except ‘Neel Aakasher Neeche’ (1959) were after the sixties, I did not include it in ‘Hemantayan 1’. I would attend to his two movies in Bengali, in the section where I would discuss his career in Calcutta/ Bengali films at length.

Section 2: Hindi films – post 1960
As a Producer / Music Director

That brings me to the section – Hemant Kumar as a producer of Hindi films, and it goes without saying that he was the music director for all the films he produced.

Since there were no signs of revival of his fortunes in Bombay, he wanted to return to Calcutta in the beginning of the 60s. But his family members were reluctant to leave Bombay. And Hemant Kumar did not want to impose his wish upon them. The lack of work as a music director in Bombay on the one hand and his earlier success as a producer in Calcutta on the other, made him toy with the idea of producing a Hindi film.

Biren Nag was an Art Director, who had worked for Guru Dutt and Dev Anand among others. He was the Art Director for films like ‘CID’(1956), ‘ Pyasa’ (1957), ‘Nau Do Gyarah’ (1957), ‘Kala Pani’ (1958), ‘Chaudahvin Ka Chand’ (1960). He won the best Art Director Award in 1960 for the film ‘Chaudhvin Ka Chand’. In a casual discussion, Biren Nag expressed his wish to direct a film, Hemant Kumar promptly responded to his wish. They decided to remake the Bengali film ‘Jighangsa’ (1951). Incidentally ‘Jighangsa’ was the last film for which Hemant Kumar had composed music for, before moving to Bombay and Biren Nag was the Art director. ‘Jighangsa’, a thriller film based on Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s ‘The Hound of the Baskervilles’ was a commercial success. Dhruva Chatterjee, who was nominated for the best story for the film ‘Chirag Kahan Roshni Kahan’ (1959), was also a good screenplay writer. Dhruava Chatterjee had written the story for the film ‘Kashti / Ferry’ (1954), for which Hemant Kumar was the music director. Hemant Kumar secured his service for writing the screenplay. He decided to employ a new face for the lead male role in his debut film ‘Bees Saal Baad’.

Hemant Kumar-BiswajitBiswajit, started his career as a stage actor with Rang Mahal and had acted in few Bengali films. Biren Nag agreed to Hemant Kumar’s suggestion, but suggested an established name for the female lead role. Biren Nag had worked with Waheeda Rehman in ‘CID’, “Pyasa’ and ‘Chaudahvin Ka Chand’ and Waheeda accepted his offer. Thus everything in place, the shooting was to start on 5th February 1960. In the meantime he had taken up the music direction for the film ‘Shahib Bibi Aur Ghulam’ at the request of Guru Dutt. I will come to that later. All of a sudden tragedy struck Hemant Kumar in his personal life. The news of the sudden demise of his mother on the morning of 2nd February 1960 left him devastated. Hemant Kumar‘s mother Kiranbala Debi was only 59 years of age. Hemant Kumar had to rush to Calcutta. He could not afford to postpone the shooting since it would have incurred a substantial additional cost. He had to shuttle between Calcutta and Bombay, simultaneously attending to the shooting and the rituals that followed after his mother’s demise.

The film ‘Bees Saal Baad’ was released in 1962 under the Geetanjali Pictures banner. Defying all odds and belying negative reviews of its detractors, it became the highest grosser at the box office for the year 1962. The film won four out of the seven Filmfare Awards it was nominated for. The song ‘Kahin Deep Jale Kahin Dil’ fetched Shakeel Badayuni and Lata Mangeshkar the best lyricist award and the best female playback singer award respectively. After ‘Nagin’, this was the second time Hemant Kumar was nominated for the best music director award, although the award was bagged by Shankar-Jaikishan for ‘Professor’.

It was the first time Hemant Kumar and Shakeel Badayuni were working together as composer-songwriter. Previously, Hemant Kumar had rendered three songs penned by Shakeel Badayuni for the films ‘Shabaab’ (1954) and ‘Ganga Jamuna’ (1961) under Naushad’s baton. Hemant Kumar and Shakeel Badayuni together fashioned five fabulous songs for the film. Hemant Kumar rendered two solos and Lata Mangeshkar three solos.

1. Beqarar karke humein yun na jaiye, film Bees Saal Baad (1962), lyrics Shakeel Badayuni

Hemant Kumar planned his second film ‘Sharmilee’. Uttam Kumar and Waheeda Rehman were cast in the lead roles. Everything in place, the launch was to start with an outdoor shoot at Asansol, when Uttam Kumar decided to withdraw himself from the film. Hemant Kumar shelved the film and asked Dhruva Chatterjee to prepare a fresh screenplay based on Daphne du Maurier’s 1938 novel ‘Rebecca’. The film ‘Kohra’ was directed by Biren Nag, starring Waheeda Rehman and Biswajeet. Elated by the nomination for the Filmfare award in his debut directorial venture, Biren Nag was in an upbeat mood. When the film was completed, Hemant Kumar had exhausted all his reserves. The film came in for lavish praise from everybody who saw it at the trial show. Hemant Kumar was not comfortable with the concluding part of the film. Biren Nag did not agree to the change suggested by him. The film was released in 1964 and bombed at the box office. Biren Nag was stunned by the reverse. Though Hemant Kumar financially suffered a setback, he was quick to recover mentally.

At this juncture the invitation for a West Indies tour came as a godsend opportunity. Hemant Kumar requested Biren Nag to join him and Bela in their West Indies tour with the hope that it would act as a much needed diversion. Biren Nag turned down the offer and deeply afflicted by the setback of ‘Kohra’ he went into a depression. The success of the trip acted as a great moral booster for Hemant Kumar. He received lot of accolades and was financially benefitted too. Towards the last leg of their trip he received the news of Biren Nag’s deteriorating health. By the time they were back in Bombay, Biren Nag was admitted to the Calcutta Medical College and Hospital, where he breathed his last. He was 42 years of age then, two years younger to Hemant Kumar. In the demise of Biren Nag, Hemant Kumar suffered a personal loss.

Kohra’ (1964) had four songs, two solos each by Hemant Kumar and Lata Mangeshkar. Presenting a song rendered by Hemant Kumar. The tune was originally set for the song ‘Ye raat tomar amar’ for a 1959 Bengali film ‘Deep Jwele Jaay’.

2. Ye nayan dare dare, film Kohra (1964), lyrics Kaifi Azmi

The next four films, ‘Faraar’ (1965), ‘Biibi Aur Makaan’ (1966), ‘Majhli Didi’ (1967) and ‘Raahgir’ (1969), did not do well at the theatres. ‘Faraar’ was the remake of the Bengali film ‘Rakta Palash’ (1962). Hemanta engaged Pinaki Mukherjee, the director of ‘Rakta Palash’, to direct the Hindi version. ‘Faraar’ had Anil Chatterjee, Balraj Sahini and Shabnam in the cast. ‘Bibi Aur Makaan’ was directed by Hrishikesh Mukherjee and Biswajit, Kalpana, Mehmood, Shabnam, and Kesto Mukherjee were in the lead roles. Hemant Kumar recycled his own tune from his successful Bengali film ‘Monihaar’ rendered by Lata Mangeshkar. The Hindi version was rendered by Hemant Kumar. Presenting both the versions:

3a. Sawan mein barkha sataaye pal pal chhin chhin barse, film Bibi Aur Makaan (1966), lyrics Gulzar

3b. Asharh shraban mane na to mon by Lata Mangeshkar, film Monihar (1966), lyrics Pulak Bandopadhyay

Majhli Didi’ was not produced under the Geetanjali Pictures banner, but Hemant Kumar had invested in its production at the request of his brother-in-law Gopal Mukherjee, who used to work in Hemant Kumar’s productions in various capacities. Kochi Sarkar and Gopal Mukherjee were long time friends. Kochi Sarkar was also close to Meena Kumari and he used to frequent her house. Later he got married to Meena Kumari’s niece. Gopal Mukherjee (Bela’s brother) wanted to produce a film and at his request Kochi Sarkar approached Meena Kumari. On receiving the consent from her, Gopal approached Hemant Kumar and Hemant Kumar agreed to invest in the film. It was a big opportunity to a do a film with Meena Kumari in the lead role. The film was produced under the banner K (Kochi Sarkar) G (Gopal Mukherjee) Pictures. Sarat Chandra Chattopadhyay’s story ‘Mejdidi’ (1915) was selected and Hrishikesh Mukherjee was given the responsibility of directing the film. Dharmendra agreed to play the male lead role. Hrishikesh Mukherjee was very meticulous in his planning and detailing. The film was well made, yet on its release in 1967, it fell flat on its face. The failure was attributed to the timing of its release. In the previous year, a few months before Majhli Didi’s release, Jupiter Pictures, a production house from Madras had released the film ‘Chhota Bhai’, based on another story, ‘Ramer Sumati’ by Sarat Chandra Chattopadhyay. Both the stories had similar endings.

Now Hemant Kumar was obsessed with film making. His next film was ‘Raahgir’, a remake of the 1963 Bengali film ‘Palatak’. Since ‘Palatak’ belongs to the period under discussion and Hemanta was the music director, it would not be inconsistent to talk about the film here. At the request of a close acquaintance who was a retired Judge from Calcutta, V Shantaram decided to produce a Bengali film. He soon spoke to his distributors in Calcutta to put him in touch with Bengali film makers. Tarun Majumdar, a young upcoming director and writer met Shantaram with a script based on a story, ‘Angti Chatujjer Bhai’, penned by the eminent poet and writer Manoj Basu. Shantaram was impressed by the script. Tarun Majumdar, Dilip Mukherjee and Sachin Mukherjee used to work as a team under the screen name Yatrik (phonetically Jatrik in Bengali) until 1963, after which each began to be credited separately. The entire shooting schedule was in Calcutta. After the post production work in Bombay, the film ‘Palatak’ produced under the Rajkamal Kalamandir banner was released in Calcutta in 1963 and was a big success. The film featured Anup Kumar, Sandhya Roy and Ruma Guha Thakurta in the lead roles. Since the script/ film demanded folk-based songs, initially Hemanta was reluctant to take up the job of music director for this film. He felt his lack of experience in this genre would be an impediment to its success. At the insistence of Tarun Majumdar he accepted the offer on the condition that Mukul Dutta should be roped in as the song writer. And the songs / music of the film too came in for generous praise. That added one more feather to his cap.

In the remaking of the film ‘Palatak’, Hemant Kumar took a huge risk, since the film typically belonged to the ‘Bengali Gharana’. Hemant Kumar was very well aware of the fact that the film may not go well with the ethos outside the Bengali viewership, yet he was willing to take the risk. For ‘Raahgir’, Hemant Kumar came back to Biswajit and Sandhya Roy was retained. Tarun Majumdar was in charge of the direction once again. The story is about Biswajit playing the role of an impulsive young man in search for ‘the meaning of life’ and is regarded as one of his most credible performances. Hemant Kumar once again was at his best as a music director. Yet the film failed to draw crowds. Let me present the Hindi and the Bengali versions of a song rendered by Hemanta Mukhopadhyay.

4a. Janam se banjara hun bandhu, film Rahgir (1969), lyrics Gulzar

4b. Jibon purer pathik re bhai, film Palatak (1963), lyrics Mukul Dutta

Unfazed by five failures on a trot, Hemant Kumar was again into production the same year. Now it was a remake of the hugely successful 1959 Bengali film ‘Deep Jwele Jai’. ‘Khamoshi’ (1970) explores the deep, emotional nature of a woman. Waheeda did complete justice to the role with great maturity. She carried the entire film through her powerful acting. She was nominated for the Filmfare Best Female Actor Award. Dharmendra‘s role too was handled well by the director Asit Sen. The film stood out for Rajesh Khanna’s performance and also for its Black & White cinematography by Kamal Bose, who won the Filmfare Award for his work in the film. Hemant Kumar and Gulzar did an outstanding job in their respective roles as composer and song writer.  The film is particularly remembered for its songs such as, ’Tum pukar lo tumhara intezaar hai’ sung by Hemant Kumar, ‘Woh shaam kuchh ajeeb thi’ by Kishore Kumar and ‘Humne dekhi hai in aankhon ki mahakti khushboo’ sung by Lata Mangeshkar. Though the film was not another failure, yet it did not live up to the expectations; at box-office the film met with moderate success.

5. Tum pukaar lo, tumhara intazaar hai, film Khamoshi (1969), lyrics Gulzar

By the end of the decade (1961-70), Hemant Kumar’s career in Hindi films was coming to an end, however there were few spillovers into the seventies, before the ‘Last Bugle’ was sounded. Ten years ago, Hemant Kumar had started his production venture in Hindi films with ‘Bees Saal Baad’. After ten years and despite repeated failures he once again entered into his next project ‘Bees Saal Pahle’. His son Jayanta Mukherjee was in one of the lead roles under the adopted film name Ritesh. It was more like a family venture. His daughter Ranu Mukherjee sang a couple of songs. Gautam Mukherjee, who later married Ranu, acted in this film. Shamsul Huda Bihari, a longtime friend of Hemant Kumar, penned the lyrics. The film released in 1972 only added to Hemant Kumar’s mounting debts and woes.

Presenting a song rendered by Lata Mangeshkar, picturised on Farida Jalal and Ritesh (Jayanta Mukherjee).

6a. Kahte hain saare hanste nazaare by Lata Mangeshkar, film Bees Saal Pahle (1972), lyrics S H Bihari

Bengali listeners will certainly recognize the eminently popular tune of this song which was composed for the Bengali film ‘Monihaar’ (1966). The song ‘Nijum sandhyay pantha pakhira’ had two versions, rendered by Lata Mangeshkar and Hemant Kumar respectively. I would present the Hemanta’s version from ‘Monihaar’ (1966) picturised on Biswajit and Sandhya Roy.

6b. Nijhuma sandhya, film Monihaar (1966), lyrics Pulak Bandopadhyay

Altogether Hemant Kumar produced eight Hindi films. Except ‘Bees Saal Baad’ and ‘Khamoshi’, the rest bombed at the box office. For these eight films Hemant Kumar composed fiftyseven songs. He rendered twenty songs, out of which fifteen were solos.

As a Music Director for other producers

Hemant Kumar scored music for eighteen Hindi films after 1960. Out of the eighteen, eight were for his in-house productions, which I have covered in detail. Rest of the ten films were ‘Sahib Bibi Aur Ghulam’ (1962), ‘Ma Beta’ (1962), ‘Bin Baadal Barsaat’ (1963), ‘Do Dil’ (1965),’Sannata’ (1966), ‘Anupama’ (1966), ‘Do Dooni Chaar’ (1968), ‘Us Raat Ke Baad’ (1970), Do Ladke Dono Kadke (1979) and Love in Canada (1979). Hemant Kumar composed fifty eight songs for these ten films. Interestingly, he rendered only eight songs out of which five were solos.

Sahib Bibi Aur Ghulam’ was an important landmark in his career as a music director. The film came in for major critical praise and won several awards, but did not do well at the box office. Hemant Kumar’s music was highly appreciated. SD Burman and Sahir Ludhiyanavi were the original choice for the music direction and song writing respectively, but SD Burman was unwell and Sahir declined the offer. When Guru Dutt approached Hemant Kumar, he was not willing to accept the offer for two reasons. Firstly, he was already in the last stages of his legwork for his first Hindi film production. And two, he was apprehensive about Guru Dutt’s unpredictable moods. Guru Dutt’s assurance dispelled his misgivings on both the counts. Hemant Kumar wanted Shakeel Badayuni to pen the songs since Shakeel was the song writer for ‘Bees Saal Baad’ too. And their combination produced seven songs, out which five can be considered as exquisite numbers; out of this five, two were rendered by Asha Bhosle for Waheeda Rehman – ‘Bhanwara bada naadan’ and ‘Meri baat rahi mere mann mein’, while Geeta Dutt sang three songs, ‘Koi door se awaaz de, ‘Piya aiso jiya mein samaay gayo reandNa jaao sainya chhuda ke bainya. The only song, ‘Saahil ki taraf kashti le chal’, sung by Hemant Kumar had a shot which showed Chhoti Bahu (Meena Kumari) resting her head on Bhootnath’s (Guru Dutt) lap in the carriage. Due to adverse reactions, Guru Dutt removed the song and the ‘offending shot’, changing the carriage scene to a dialogue exchange between Chhoti Bahu and Bhootnath. Hemant Kumar used this tune in the 1966 film ‘Anupama’ for which he was the music director.

Anupama’ was directed by Hrishikesh Mukherjee. The movie stars Dharmendra and Sharmila Tagore in the lead roles. The film did reasonably well at the box office and its music and songs came in for praise.

7. Ya dil ki suno duniyawalo, film Anupama (1966), lyrics Kaifi Azmi

I would present one more song for which Hemant Kumar scored music for a film outside his own banner. ‘Bin Baadal Barsaat’ (1963) was a thriller movie featuring Asha Parekh, Biswajit and Mehmood in the lead characters. The film was directed by Jyoti Swaroop and produced under the Uttam Chitra Banner (NC Sippy). Hemant Kumar worked again for NC Sippy under the Uttam Chitra Banner in 1965 for the film ‘Do Dil’ directed by Hrishikesh Mukherjee. As we have seen earlier, whenever Hemant Kumar and Sakeel Badayuni came together, they produced sheer magic. After ‘Bees Saal Baad’ and ‘Sahib Bibi Aur Ghulam’, the duo combined for the last time to produce some eminently listenable numbers for the film ‘Bin Baadal Barsaat’ (1963). Presenting a solo rendered by Hemant Kumar from this film.

8. Zindagi kitni khubsurat hai, film Bin Baadal Barsaat (1963), lyrics Shakeel Badayuni

As a playback singer for other Music Directors – Hindi Films

Hemant Kumar’s total output as a playback singer declined significantly during the decade 1961-70. He rendered approximately 35 songs in 26 films as against 141 songs in 81 films in the previous decade (1951-60). His total output in Hindi films from 1971 to 1989 was only 14. I would present two songs he rendered for other composers during this period.

Based on the 1892 short story by Rabindranath Thakur, ‘Kabuliwala’ (1961) had Balraj Sahni in the title role. The Bengali version was made by Tapan Sinha in 1954 and had Chobi Biswas in the main role. Hemen Gupta made it in Hindi in 1961. Let me present the song rendered by Hemant Kumar for this film,

9. Ganga aaye kahan se, Ganga jaye kahan re, film Kabuliwala (1961) lyrics Gulzar, music Salil Choudhury

Let me do a summing up of his career in Bombay.

Hemant Kumar 2After the success of ‘Nagin’ (1954), he did not show enough discretion in his selection of films. He accepted almost all the offers that came his way to score music. Hemant Kumar states in his biography that he could not assess his market rate after Nagin’s success. He accepted offers to score music for Rs 12000/- to 15000/- per film. An offer of Rs. 20000/- seemed to him a huge sum at that moment. He rues his decision and further states that he should have restricted his number of films in Bombay and raised his remuneration. But that was an afterthought and one cannot set the clock back. In the process he started losing his position as a leading singer too, which he had gained especially after the success of ‘Anarkali’ (1953).

In order to get back his foothold in Hindi films Hemant Kumar ventured into production. After the success of his first two films as a producer he lost his way. Instead of being deterred by failures, he was sucked deep into the vortex of production. This not only affected him financially but also harmed his singing career in Bombay. In the process, he even lost his toehold which he was able to gain after ‘Bees Saal Baad’ and ‘Sahib Bibi Aur Ghulam’.

Reverting back to the first part of the question, “Was Hemant Kumar able to consolidate his position and career in Bombay…………”, to state that he failed to capitalize on his extraordinary success would be a simplistic statement. Irrespective of the box office outcome, Hemant Kumar had a large number of highly listenable songs. Ashok Vaishanvji had rightly pointed out this fact in one of his follow up articles on Hemant Kumar. I quote “As it happens with the majority of the film songs, the songs from the films that did well on the box office had longer recall value in the minds of the listeners”.

Providence conspires to make things happen the moment one definitely commits oneself. A whole stream of events gradually proceeds from the decision. But capitalizing on such providential help is another matter. Success and failures are relative. This was evidently true in Hemant Kumar’s career. He had his own share of defining moments and disappointments. And there was the luck factor too. As it often happens, his fortune did not favour him as it did earlier. Hemant Kumar, it seems, believed in destiny and coped up with the ecstatic highs and appalling lows in his career philosophically. He could accept the fact that stardom is transient and the real happiness lies in the act of creation. He was blessed with loads of patience and that helped him to take things as it came and he moved on with his search for the ultimate bliss in his own creations.

Borrowing lyricist Yogesh’s words.
Jeevan ek pyaas hai,
Sabhi ko kuchh talaash hai
Jeevan ek pyaas hai

Jinki hum talaash mein umra bhar chale
koi jaanta nahin wo kahan mile
Phir bhi tooti nahin ye jo aas hai
Sabhi Ko Kuchh Talaash Hai
Jeevan ek pyaas hai
Sabhi ko kuchh ki talaash hai

10. Raahi tu mat ruk jaana, film Door Gagan Ki Chaaon Mein (1964), lyrics Shailendra, music Kishore Kumar

Section 3:

Hemant Kumar 3The saying, ‘as one door closes another one opens’, was very much true in Hemant Kumar’s career. As we see a downward curve in his assignments in Bombay, there was an upward swing in Bengali films in Calcutta. Before I broach the subject, I would like to touch upon the churning that was happening in Bengali film world during the fifties and Hemanta Mukhopadyhay’s ‘positioning’ therein.

When Hemanta Mukhopadyay left Calcutta in search of greener pastures in Bombay, Bengal film industry was poised for a major change. The old order was gradually withering away and giving way to a new one. The gradual eclipse of New Theatres and similar production houses, the effects of partition on the market and the cine goers, and the emergence of glamorous Hindi films in a big way had a definite impact on the Bengali cine watchers. They were moving away from regional cinema. Wooed by the popularity and demand for Hindi cinema, theatre owners were inclined to show Hindi movies. Younger generations of that period were yearning for something different. Responding to the needs of the situation Bengali Cinema went through a process of transformation. Effective changes especially in the areas of content, narration, style and presentation, catering to the taste of the masses was bringing back the audience to the theatres. Awakening to a new dawn, Bengali film industry was entering into its golden period. 1953-54 marked the watershed in Bengali film industry. While the popular cinema was getting back on the tracks, Bengali cinema also had space for serious or parallel cinema and had its exclusive audience. And there was an intersecting overlap too. There were enough audience for all the three categories, the popular cinema having the major share. While directors like Nirmal Dey, Ajay Kar, Sudhir Mukherjee and others were nourishing the popular cinema, Satyajit Ray, Mrinal Sen and Ritwik Ghatak were creating waves on the other front, and directors like Tapan Sinha and Tarun Majumdar were making their own brand of films which may be considered as the bridge between the two. Even as the appearance of two youthful faces, Uttam Kumar and Suchitra Sen, injected the much needed star appeal, Soumitra Chatterjee, Kali Banerjee, Supriya Devi, Sharmila Tagore emerged in the Bengali film scenario through the parallel cinema. Hemanta Mukhopadhyay, Nachiketa Ghosh , Sudhin Dasgupta and Shyamal Mitra as music directors, Gouriprasanna Majumdar, Pulak Bandopadhyay and Mukul Dutta as song writers contributed immensely to the resurgence of the popular Bengali cinema. Parallel cinema too was enriched by musicians like Pandit Ravi Shankar, Ustad Ali Akbar Khan and Ustad Vilayat Khan. And the above list is not exhaustive.

Removed from the rejuvenation that was happening in the east, Hemant Kumar was cementing his place in the west. In 1954 he had reached his pinnacle in Bombay coinciding with the watershed period in Bengali films. This provided the perfect launching pad for his re-emergence in Bengali films. And when the offers came, Hemanta riding on the chariot of success entered the field with aplomb in 1955. Hemanta as a composer and a singer in Bengali films was high on popularity for the next 25 to 30 years. Very few composers / singers have enjoyed such a huge popularity and fan following. To cover the entire success story spanning three decades would be a tall order.

First I would give a statistical overview of Hemanta Mukhopadhyay’s work for the period under discussion

Then I would try to focus on a few important associations (and some relevant Information) that was instrumental to further his career in Calcutta.

I would follow it up with the two in-house productions in Bengali, before concluding.

Statistical overview of Hemanta Mukhopadhyay’s Bengali Films

A year wise break-up from 1955 to 1960 will give an indication of his steady rise as a music director in Bengali Films.

1955: 2 films – Shaapmochan and Suryamukhi
1956: Nil
1957: 3 films – Shesh Parichay, Taaser Ghar and Harano Sur
1958: 4 films – Lukochuri, Shikaar, Jautuk and Suryatoran
1959: 6 films – Neel Aakasher Neeche, Marutirtha Hinglaaj, Deep Jwele Jai, Khelaghar, Sonar Harin and Kshan-iker Atithi
1960: 5 films – Kuhak, Khokababur Pratyabartan, Baishe Shraban, Gariber Meye and Shesh Prjanta

In the 20 films, he composed roughly 81 songs out which he rendered 43 solos.

As a playback singer for other music directors he approximately rendered 70 songs in 43 films between 1955 and 1960.

And a synopsis of Hemanta Mukhopadhyay’s career in Bengali films and his NFSs post 1960 would give yet another vivid picture of his consolidation.

As a music director:
1961-70: 51 films; composed approximately 231 songs, rendered around 122 songs out of which 89 were solos.
1971-80: 39 films; composed approximately 195 songs, rendered around   80 songs out of which 62 were solos.
1981-88: 26 films; composed approximately 164 songs rendered around   43 songs out of which 26 were solos.
Total: 116 films; composed 590 songs, rendered 245 songs out of which 177 were solos.
Besides he scored music for a Bengali Film ‘Nyay Bichaar’ produced in Bangladesh in 1989
.

Again in 1989, Biswajit signed Hemanta to score music for a bilingual film. One song for the Bengali version ‘Bhalobasar Raat’ was recorded on 23rd September 1989, three days prior to his demise.

As a playback singer under other music directors:
1961-1970: Roughly 117 songs (approximately 69 films)
1971-1980: Roughly 117 songs (approximately 80 films)
1981-1990: Roughly 66 songs (approximately 50 films)
After 1990 three more films were released for which he rendered 3 songs.
Total 303 songs; this includes songs from unreleased films.

Bengali NFSs including Rabindra Sangeet (Records and cassettes)
1961-1990:  roughly 370 songs. This approximately includes 50+ self-composed songs.

Besides, he lent his voice for 12 Geetinatya (musical drama) records, out of which 6 were Rabindra Geetinatya.

Some important associates in Hemanta Mukhopadhyay’s career:

Hemanta once told Pulak Bandopadhyay, the lyricist with whom he had worked extensively in his later part of his career, that two thing are important for success in one’s career; ‘Yogyata’ (eligilbility/ potential) and ‘Yogayog’ (associations/contacts/ connections). As regards ‘Yogyata’, I need not stress on this point, since it is very much evident that Hemanta had plenty of this trait. I would be discussing in brief, his association with some select set of individuals – lead actors, directors, song writers and others. In the process I would be bypassing a lot more than those I would be covering. But I am sure readers would understand and bear with me. I am sure we will have more opportunities in future to do justice to the rest. Let me start with Uttam Kumar and Soumitra Chatterjee, the two male lead actors who dominated Bengali films during the golden period.

Hemant Kumar-Uttam KumarUttam Kumar was a one-man phenomenon who along with Suchitra Sen is credited for the revival of the Bengali films in the 50s. Actually Hemanta’s association with Uttam Kumar started in the year 1951 when he rendered two songs for Uttam in the film ‘Sahajatri’ under Robin Chattopadhyay’s music direction. Uttam was then in the nascent stage of his career. In 1953, Hemanta rendered four songs in a periodic film ’Bou Thakuranir Haat’ based on a story by the same name penned by Rabindranath Thakur. The film had Uttam Kumar in the casting but none of the songs rendered by Hemanta was picturised on him. ‘Sahajatri’ was Uttam’s fourth film. It took another four films for Uttam Kumar to come of age. ‘Basu Paribar’ (1952) was his first hit movie. And as I have stated earlier, 1953 was the watershed year for the Bengali film industry. ‘Shaare Chuattor’ (1953) was the first film Uttam Kumar and Suchitra Sen came together and it established them as the first couple of the Bengali films right away. The film became a box-office topper and there was no looking back for the pair. Uttam-Suchitra featured in six films in 1954. It must be said that though Uttam-Suchitra pair was a huge draw, at the same time each had their own fan following and cinephiles would flock to the theatres even when only one of them was present. Excluding the six films they were featured together, Uttam Kumar acted in 8 more films and Suchitra Sen acted in 3 more films in the year 1954.

The year 1955 marked the comeback of Hemanta Mukhopadhyay in a big way. He had his own fan following and after his recent success in Bombay, he too was in demand. When the producer of the next Uttam-Suchitra starrer approached him for scoring music for ‘Shapmochan’ (1955), he latched on to the opportunity. And this film too turned out to be a box-office sensation. All the four songs composed and rendered by Hemanta for Uttam Kumar were hits. By the end of 1950s, Hemanta Mukhopadhyay had established himself as the undisputed numero uno of Bengali Film music and out of the 20 Bengali films he scored music for, between 1955 and 1960, eleven of them were Uttam Kumar starrers. Besides ‘Shapmochan’ (1955), Hemanta scored music for two more Uttam-Suchitra starrers – Harano Sur (1957) and Suryatoran (1958) – where he rendered 4 songs for Uttam. Even non-Uttam films like ‘Suryamukhi’, ‘Shesh Parichay’, ‘Lukochuri’, ‘Kshaniker Athiti’ and ‘Bayisher Shraban’ did very well at the theatres. Between 1961 and 1980, Hemanta gave music direction for 16 more films in which Uttam Kumar acted (1961-70: 11 films, 1971-80: 5 films) and only two of them were Uttam-Suchitra starrers, Saptapadi (1961) and Nabaraag (1971).

Saptapadi’ (1961) was another blockbuster film of the first romantic pair of Bengali cinema. Mesmerising music direction of Hemanta Mukhpadhyay and playback singing by him and Sandhya Mukherjee added to the unprecedented popularity of the film. The story was based on a 1958 novel written by Tarasankar Bandyopadhyay. The evergreen Song ‘Ei path jodi na shesh hoto’ is one of the most popular Bengali duets of the golden period. Presenting the song,

11a. Ei poth jodi na shesh hoy, with Sandhya Mukherjee, film Saptapadi (1961), lyics Gouriprasanna Majumdar, music Hemanta Mukhopadhyay

Hemanta used the same tune for another duet in the 1963 Hindi film ‘Bin Baadal Barsaat’. It was a thriller movie featuring Asha Parekh, Biswajit and Mehmood in the lead characters.

11b. Ek baar zara phir kah do, with Lata Mangeshkar, film Bin Baadal Barsaat, lyrics Shakeel Badayuni, music Hemant Kumar

The next song is from another 1961 film ‘Dui Bhai’. Uttam Kumar and Biswajit were cast in the role of two brothers and Sabitri Chatterjee was cast opposite Uttam Kumar in this film. Presenting another popular song rendered by Hemanta and picturised on Uttam Kumar and Biswajit.

12. Tare bole deo, film Dui Bhai (1961), lyrics Gouriprasanna Majumdar, music Hemanta Mukhopadhyay

Hemanta must have rendered around 55 to 60 songs, under other music directors, in films in which Uttam Kumar acted. And all of them were not picturised on him, some of them were background songs or surrogate songs. And the interesting point is that the majority of the songs Hemanta rendered for Uttam Kumar were lapped by the cine goers and music lovers. It is not that Hemanta dominated Uttam Kumar’s movies as a playback singer. There were other singers like Shyamal Mitra, Manabendra Mukherjee and in the later stages Manna Dey and Kishore Kumar also sang for Uttam Kumar. And yet surprisingly, fans readily considered Hemanta as the most preferred voice of Uttam Kumar. I have selected two films in which Hemanta lent his voice for Uttam Kumar where the music was scored by relatively lesser known music directors.

Shesh Anka’ (1963) a thriller film directed by Haridas Bhattacharya was produced under the Kalpana Movies banner. The film featured Uttam Kumar, Sharmila Tagore, Sabitri Chatterjee, Utpal Dutta and Bikash Ray among others. The film was loosely inspired by the 1958 film ‘Chase a Crooked Shadow’. It was remade in Tamil in 1964 as ‘Puthiya Paravai’. Presenting a song rendered by Hemanta for the film,

13. Ami to jani, film Shesh Anka (1963), lyrics Shyamal Gupta, music Pabitra Chatterjee

Sonar Khancha’ (1973), a very unusual film, a romantic tragedy, that takes the viewer with it to a height of pathos. Brilliant performances by the evergreen Uttam Kumar and Aparna Sen make the film worth watching.

14. Ke jane ko ghanta, film Sonar Khancha (1973), lyrics Pulak Bandopadhyay, music Bireswar Chatterjee

Soumitra Chatterjee was another big name in Bengali films. He was almost eight and a half years younger to Uttam Kumar. He made his debut in the third part of Apu trilogy, directed by Satyajit Ray. ‘Apur Sansar’ (1959) was Satyajit Ray’s fifth film. He acted in 14 out of the 28 Satyajit Ray’s films in Bengali. Uttam Kumar and Soumitra Chatterjee acted together in at least 8 films and Hemanta had scored music for only one of the films, Pankhiraj (1980). Incidentally, ‘Pankhiraj’ was released in the same year when Uttam Kumar passed away at the age of 53.

Before I explore Hemanta’s association with Soumitra let me present a song from the film ‘Stree’ (1972). Hemanta rendered four songs in the film where Uttam and Soumitra acted together. All the four songs Hemanta rendered in this film were lip-synced by Soumitra Chatterjee. The music was by Nachiketa Ghosh, a name to reckon with. The film was also a box office hit. Presenting another popular number where Manna Dey sings for Uttam and Hemanta for Soumitra. By the beginning of the seventies, Manna Dey had gradually replaced Hemanta as Uttam’s main voice. But that did not affect Hemanta’s popularity.

15. Hajar takar jhaarbati ta, with Manna Dey, film Stree (1972), lyrics Gouriprasanna Majumdar, music Nachiketa Ghosh

By early sixties, Hemanta had tiled his place smoothly in Bengali films, and if I say that his popularity and fan following at this stage could be matched with that of Uttam Kumar, it would not be an exaggeration. And the success of ‘Neel Akasher Neeche’ (1959) pushed his stocks further. Hemanta’s association with Soumitra Chatterjee started during this period with the film ‘Swaralipi’ (1961) directed by Asit Sen. Thus another long and successful association was shaped. Within a short time Soumitra had emerged as a rising star and whose name would be talked in equal terms with Uttam Kumar for the next twenty years. Hemanta scored music for 29 films in which Soumitra Chatterjee acted, the break-up being, 1961-70: 14 films, 1971-80: 12 films and 1981-89: 5 films. I would present two more songs picturised on Soumitra.

16. Khirki theke singha duar, lyrics Pulak Bandopadhyay, film Stree (1972), music Nachiketa Ghosh

17. O aakash sona sona, lyrics Mintu Ghosh, film Ajana Path (1967), music Hemanta Mukhopadhyay

Gouriprasanna Majumdar and Pulak Bandopadhyay were the two prominent song writers with whom Hemanta collaborated most. The two song writers together penned roughly 52% of the songs for which Hemanta composed music in his career. And they had almost an equal share. Hemanta used Rabindranath songs on several occasions. Another lyricist who deserves mention here is Mukul Dutta. Rabindranath and Mukul Dutta must have accounted for 20% of his songs. Even the figures for the period 1961 to 1990 show almost an identical trend. Between Gouriprasanna Majumdar and Pulak Bandopadyay, the former dominates the period between 1947 and 1970, whereas in the latter period between 1971 and 1990 Pulak Bandopadhyay was Hemanta’s main song writer. Gouriprasanna and Hemanta worked together for the first time for the film ‘Purbaraag’ (1947). ‘Purbaraag’ was Gouriprsanna’s first film as a song writer and Hemanta’s second film as a music director. Their association was reestablished with the film ‘Suryamukhi” in the year 1955. Pulak Bandopadhyay’s first film with Hemanta was ‘Monihaar’ (1966). Roughly 40% of the songs Hemanta rendered for other music directors were penned by this pair. Interestingly, here too they had an equal share.

Among the music directors (90+) for whom Hemanta had lent his voice I would like mention two names, Nachiketa Ghosh and Robin Chattopadhyay. Hemanta’s songs for these two music directors should account for 22% to 25% of the songs he rendered for other composers. Hemanta’s first song for Robin Chattopadhyay was in the year 1946 for the film ‘Saath Number Bari’ and I have mentioned earlier Hemanta’s first song for Uttam Kumar was also under Robin Chattopadhyay’s music direction for the film ‘Sahayatri’(1951). Let me present an iconic lullaby and a wonderful composition, most likely picturised on Asit Baran. The video link to the song is not available, presenting an audio link to the song.

18. Ghum jay oi chand megh korider saathi, film Mayar Sangsaar (1962) lyrics Pranab Ray, music Robin Chattopadhyay

Nachiketa Ghosh was a qualified doctor, but his lure for film music made him opt for a profession as music composer. His entry into the Bengali film world coincided with the watershed period. His First film was ‘Boudir Bon’ (1953). He was one of the most acclaimed music directors of the golden period and had scored music for more than 60 films. His career was cut short by his untimely death in the year 1976 at the age of 51. His first association with Hemanta was in the year 1956 for the film ‘Asamapta’. In the 50s and 60s Nachiketa-Hemanta-Gouriprasanna team proved to be a winning combination. And the trio was very close to each other in their personal as well as professional life. Posting a hymn which is part of ‘Moha Mudgara’ (popularly known as Bhaja Govindam) composed by Adi Sankaracharya. The hymn appears three times in the movie ‘Sannayasiraja’ (1975), I am posting the video version lip-synced by Uttam Kumar. The song starts at 03:10 of the following link.

19. Ka tava kanta kaste putraha, film ‘Sannayasiraja’ (1975), lyrics Adi Shankaracharya, music Nachiketa Ghosh

Hemanta Mukhopadhyay in his long career as a music director (in Bengali films) was associated with more than 50 directors. Among the fifty+, Tarun Majumdar (20), Ajoy Kar (15) and Agradoot (10) would together account for almost one-third of his films.

Agradoot is not the name of a particular director, but was a group of film technicians signing collectively as director, a phenomenon unique to Bengali Cinema (as far as my knowledge goes). The group formed in 1946 was active up to the end of 1980s. Hemanta scored music for them in ten films and their association produced fruitful results in 1950s and 60s. Other well-known collectives include Sabyasachi, Agragami, Yatrik, Chitra Rath and Chitra Sathi.

Ajay Kar too initially started his directorial venture with such a group known by the name Sabyasachi Collective, which also included Kanan Devi and Benoy Chatterjee. His first independent film as director was ‘Jighangsa’ in 1951. Hemanta’s association with Ajay Kar started with this film and lasted till Hemanta’s death. In all Hemanta scored music for 15 films which would roughly account for 50% of Ajoy Kar’s directorial ventures. Ajoy Kar was one of the most sought after directors of the golden period and he was considered as the mentor to Uttam Kumar. His association with Hemanta Mukhopadhyay resulted in blockbusters like ‘Harano Sur’, ‘Saptapadi’, ‘Saat Paake Bandha’, ‘Khelaghar’ to name a few.

Tarun Majumdar, too, like Ajoy Kar started his career as a director with a group called Yaatrik/Jatrik. His first film with Hemanta was ‘Palatak’ (1963), when Tarun Majumdar was a part of the group. He was the brain behind this successful film produced by Shantaram. I have discussed the film while presenting the songs 4a & 4b. After ‘Palatak’ Hemanta became the permanent music director for Tarun Majumdar. Out of the 34 films Tarun Majumdar directed, 3 were before ‘Palatak’ and 8 were after Hemanta’s demise. And out of the remaining 23 films Hemanta composed music for 20. I would present three songs from the films directed by Tarun Majumdar and composed and rendered by Hemanta. First a popular Holi song from the film ‘Balika Badhu’ (1967)

20. Laag laag ranger bhelki, film Balika Badhu (1967), lyrics Gouriprasanna Majumdar, music Hemanta Mukhopadhyay

Hemanta could not take up any outside assignments in 1971-72, due to his involvement in his own production, ‘Anindita’ (1972) for which he was also the director. Besides, he had to travel to London twice for recording the songs for the film ‘Siddharth’ (1972) directed by Conrad Rooks. After ‘Anindita’ and ‘Siddharth’ when Hemanta had no films in hand, Tarun Majumdar stood by his side and gave him three assignments, ‘Shreeman Prithviraj’ (1973), ‘Phuleswari’ (1974) and ‘Thagini (1974). And all of them were well received by the audience. Out of the three ‘Phuleswari’ deserves a special mention. This film had a few songs belonging to a genre called ‘Paala Gaan’, a folk ballad based on musical narrative. In the beginning Hemanta was hesitant to take up the assignment, but Tarun Majumdar took him to Boral village where the veteran ‘Paala Gaan’ singer of yesteryears Krishnakali Bhattacharya resided. He was in his eighties and subject to irritable moods. To him Hemanta was just another name. Hemanta like an obedient student learnt the nuances of ‘Paala Gaan’ and humbly accepted the admonishment from the veteran authority, whenever he made mistakes. This depicts Hemanta’s character as a serious musician, learner and a human being. It was a milestone movie in the history of Bengali films both for its story as well as for its songs and it success once again revived Hemanta’s fortunes in Bengali films. Thus Tarun Majumdar’s association had a very significant influence in Hemanta’s career.

The film had 12 songs and Hemanta rendered 6 of them, Manna Dey 2, Haridhan Mukhopadhyay, Anup Ghoshal, Aarti Mukherjee one each. Sandhya Mukhopadhyay and Aarti Mukhopadhyay together rendered a duet. All the songs became eminently popular. I have selected the most popular song out of the six solos rendered by Hemanta for the film. It does not belong to the folk genre mentioned here.

21. Jeona danao bandhu, film Phuleswari (1974), lyrics Pulak Bandopadhyay, music Hemanta Mukhopadhyay

I had to leave out many significant relationships/ associations in Hemanta’s life, but the one important name that I must mention would be that of Lata Mangeshkar. After ‘Ananda Math’ Hemanta had established an excellent relationship with Lata. Hemanta in his biography states that Lata never accepted any remuneration for singing in his in-house productions. He also mentions that Lata never turned down any request made by him but always warned him of his fair-weather friends.

In 1953, Lata Mangeshkar recorded her first Rabindra Sangeet album at the request of Hemanta Mukhopadhyay. Both the songs, ‘Tomar holo shuru’ and ‘Madhu gandhe bara’, were duets with Hemanta and recorded under his direction. The album was released sometime in June-July 1953.The same year, again at the request of Hemanta, she recorded two more Rabindra Sangeet solos, ‘Hriday amaar naache re’ and ‘Sawan gagane ghor ghanaghata’ for the film ‘Bou Thakuranir Haat’ (1953), under Dwijen Choudhury’s music direction. The initial guidance was provided by Hemanta. In April 1954, she came to Calcutta at the invitation of Hemanta and Bela and stayed at Hemanta’s house at Bhawanipur. She also accepted an invitation to participate in the ‘Polila Baisakh / Bengali New Year Day’ programme held at Basusree Cinema Hall.

In 1985, a grand celebration was organized, at the Netaji Indoor Stadium at Calcutta, to commemorate Hemanta Mukherjee’s completion of 50 years of his career in music. Hemanta wanted Lata’s presence and she had accepted his invitation. A few days before the scheduled date, she conveyed her inability to attend the program due to health problems. But on the morning of the celebration day, she flew in and drove straight to Hemanta’s residence and participated in the celebrations in the evening and presented him with the memento on behalf of his fans and admirers.

Lata rendered 34 songs in Bengali films under Hemanta’s music direction, which is her maximum in Bengali films for any music director. However it should be mentioned that Lata’s first Bengali film was ‘Amar Bhoopali’ (1952), in which she rendered six songs under Vasant Desai’s music direction and she rendered maximum number of Basic songs/ NFSs (35) for Salil Chowdhury. Hemanta played a crucial role in Lata’s engagement in Bengali film and non-film music and her involvement enriched Bengali film music. Presenting a popular duet from the film ‘Adwitiya’(1968),

22. Chanchala mann aanmona hoi with Lata Mangeshkar, film Adwitiya (1968), lyrics Mukul Dutta. Music Hemanta Mukhopadhyay

Lata Mangeshkar scored music in four films using the pseudonym ‘Anandaghan‘ and it is probably only once that Hemanta lent his voice to a Lata Mangeshkar tune in the film ‘Marathi Tituka Melvava’ (1964). The song, ‘Marathi Pavool Padate Pudhe’ had three more singers- Lata Mangeshkar, Usha Mangeshkar and Hridaynath Mangeshkar. Hemanta also sang several popular Marathi songs. ‘Mee dolkara, dolkara, dolakra dariya cha raaja’ with Lata Mangeshkar was one of the popular numbers. Salil Chowdhury was so much impressed by this composition by Hridaynath Mangeshkar that he wrote the Bengali lyrics for it and had it re-recorded. I have neither posted any Non Film Song (NFS) nor any regional songs till now. This gives me the opportunity to present a NFS in Bengali and its original version in Marathi.

23a. De dol dol, Bengali NFS (1970) with Lata Mangeshkar, lyrics Salil Chowdhury, music Hridaynath Mangeshkar

23b. Mee dolkara dolkara dolkara dariya cha raja, Marathi NFS (1969), with Lata Mangeshkar, lyrics Shanta Shalkey, music Hridaynath Mangeshkar

Having dealt with some of the associations which turned out be significant during the course of his journey in Bengali films, let me briefly touch upon his personal side, before I shift my focus to Hemanta Mukhopadyay’s in house production ventures in Bengali films.

By the end of 1970s Hemanta had decided to return to Calcutta for good. He realized that his future lay in Bengali films. And he had a huge fan-following and like any funkaar he too loved to be among his admires. And at the same time he never shirked from his responsibilities and was caring person too. He was a dutiful son to his parents, and then met the needs of his younger siblings and Bela’s brothers and sister till they settled down and were able to manage their own affairs. Even his bonding with his school friends was exemplary. His school friend Samaresh Roy was employed as his assistant music director from mid-sixties. His brother Amal Mukherjee also joined him as assistant music director around the same time. He also independently scored music and rendered a few songs. ‘Bees Saal Pehle’, which Hemanta probably produced to launch his son in Hindi films, flopped. Before leaving Bombay he set up a music/ recording studio at his residence ‘Geetanjali’ in Bombay for his son. After the success of ‘Baalika Badhu’ he got Moushumi Chatterjee engaged to his son Jayanta Mukherjee. After a few years he got her daughter Ranu Mukherjee married to Goutam Mukherjee who was a musician and a professional arranger in his own right. His brother-in-law Gopal Mukherjee managed his affairs in Bombay and Calcutta. After the demise of his father in 1970, he established a charitable medical centre at Baharu and this is only one of his many philanthropic activities. Finally he with his wife Bela shifted to Calcutta and stayed at Bela’s sister Abha’s house on rent. During the time when Hemanta finally shifted to Calcutta, his aspiration to direct a movie drove him to produce a film in Bengali. During the same time he got an assignment to score music for an Indo-American film ‘Siddharth’.

Hemanta Mukherjee’s Bengali Productions:

The first film produced by Hemanta Mukhopadhyay was under Hemanta-Bela Productions banner. ‘Neel Aakasher Neeche’ was a Bengali black and white film based on the story, ‘Chini Ferriwala’, written by the eminent Hindi poet and writer Mahadevi Verma. The simple yet touching story set in the 1930s, revolves around a bond between an honest Chinese hawker, Wang Lu and Basanti, the wife of a lawyer who is engaged in political activities. Basanti is arrested and imprisoned causing Wang Lu to get involved with her political group. He later returns to China to join the resistance movement against the Japanese invasion of China in 1931. Actually the seed of this film was sowed sometime in mid-1950s, when Bhupen Hazarika came to Bombay, seeking help from Hemanta to get Lata Mangeshkar to sing for his next Asamiya film ‘Era Bator Sur’.

After the recording of the songs, Bhupen Hazarika shared the script/ story of ‘Chini Ferriwala’ with Hemanta. Bhupen Hazrika wanted to direct the film and it seemed he was looking for a producer. Uttam Kumar and Arundhati Devi were to play the lead roles. Initially, Hemanta was not impressed by the script written by Mrinal Sen, who had directed only one film earlier in 1955. Another script written by an experienced script writer too was not to his satisfaction. The project remained in the backburner for a month or so. In the meantime Bhupen Hazarika had lost interest in the project. On the advice of his close acquaintance Shantu, who used to look after his dealings in Calcutta, Hemanta took Mrinal Sen to Bombay and asked him to rewrite the script within seven days. Thrilled by the outcome, Mrinal Sen was asked to direct the film. Uttam Kumar eased himself out of the film, refusing to spend long hours at the make-up room. Finally Kali Banerjee and Manju Dey replaced Uttam Kumar and Arundhati Devi. The problem regarding the make-up of Chini Ferriwala was resolved with the help of the veteran make-up artist, Haripada Chandra, who had shifted to Madras then.

Neel Akasher Neechey’ will be remembered for its in-depth storytelling. Three years after its successful run in theatres, the film became the first to earn a ban in the post-Independent India when tensions on the Sino-Indian border escalated to a war in 1962. When the ban was lifted after two or three months, the film revived the interest of the cine-goers and had a successful rerun. There were two remarkable songs in the film, ‘Neel akasher neeche ei prithibi’ and ‘O nodi re ekti kotha shudhai shudhu tomaare’, both rendered by Hemanta.

In 1971, at the recommendation of Simi Garewal, Conrad Rooks approached Hemanta Mukhopadhyay to compose a song for his forthcoming Indo-American Production ‘Siddharth’. Hemanta Mukherjee had to travel to London to meet Conrad Rooks. When Rooks explained the situation and wanted an Indian song, Hemanta sang ‘O nodi re ekti kotha shudhai shudhu tomaare’ and explained to him the meaning. The song went well with situation. After recording the song he returned in April. After two months he had to go to London again. Conrad Rooks wanted to include one more Indian song in the voice of Hemanta Kumar and his first choice was the song ‘Jai Jagadisha Hare’. Hemanta could convince Rooks that the song would not go with the situation. And finally the song ‘Pather klanti bhule sneho bhora kole Tobo maago, bolo kobe shitol hobo’ from the 1959 film ‘Maru Tirtha Hinglaj’ was selected for recording. When the film released on the international circuit, Hemanta songs were generously appreciated. Born in an ancient city on the bank of River Ganga, Hemanta Mukhopadhyay spent a major part of his youth in another riverine city. Rivers always fascinated him and used it as metaphor to convey his philosophy in life. Since the version from the film ‘Siddharth’ was posted in the comments section of the first part I am posting the original version from ‘Neel Aakasher Neeche’ here.

24. O nodi re ekti kotha shudhai shudhu tomaare, film ‘Neel Aakasher Neeche’ (1959), lyrics Gouriprasanna Majumdar, music Hemanta Mukhopadhyay

Driven by the desire to direct a film, Hemanta Mukhopadhyay decided to produce a film in Bengali. This was his last production venture. The film ‘Anindita’, was based on a story by Ashapurna Devi and had Subhendu Chatterjee and Moushumi Chatterjee in the lead roles. Amal Mukheree, Bela Mukherjee and Samaresh Roy assisted Hemanta in music direction. The film did moderately well at the box office. Hemanta obtained the permission of Pankaj Mullick and the Vishwabahrati Board to use the song ‘Diner sheshe ghumer deshe’ in this film. Hemanta in the initial period of his career adopted Pankaj Mullick’s style. He was also a huge fan of Pankaj Mullick and later had the opportunity to work closely with him. Thus it was a fitting tribute to his mentor. The song once again reiterates his attraction for riparian songs.

25. Diner sheshe ghumer deshe, film Anindita (1972), lyrics Rabindrantah Tagore, music Pankaj Mullick

Hemanta’s fan following had increased manifold after his resurgence. In 1961, during Rabindranath Tagore’s birth centenary, HMV recorded a number of Rabindra Sangeet rendered by Hemanta Mukopadhyay. This too proved to be a major commercial success. Since 1960s he was the predominant and lead male voice in many of Tagore’s musical dramas like “Valmiki Pratibha”, “Shyama”, “Shapmochan”,”Chitrangada” and “Chandalika“. Thus he established himself as one of the foremost exponents of Rabindrasangeet and perhaps the most sought after male singer all-round the year. Hemanta had to undertake several overseas concert tours in this period to places where Bengali/ Indian diaspora was spread. He suffered from diabetes, severe back pain, skin allergy and heart problems due to his hectic life style, excessive work pressure and anxiety which he never shared with anybody. In 1980, Hemanta suffered a major heart attack that severely affected his vocal capabilities, especially his breath control. Yet he was the most sought after artist till his end and he too loved to be among his fans, followers and admires.

In September 1989, after returning from a hectic and successful tour of Bangladesh, he was forced to stay indoors for a few days. He was to leave for Bombay on Tuesday the 26th September. Right from his Bombay days, Hemanta and Bela preferred to spend the Durga Puja with the film fraternity at Bombay and the Paila Baisakh at Calcutta. On 22nd September he travelled to Basirhat by road, roughly a 70 Kms from Kolkata, for a concert there. On his return that night Bela found him tired but in a buoyant mood and as per his driver Sanat ‘Dada was in his old form and rendered 25 to 30 songs to an enthralled audience’. Next day morning he recorded a song for Biswajeet’s forthcoming film ‘Bhalobasar Raat’. In the evening he had program at Kalamandir, Kolkata. He returned with a fever. Even before he stepped out of his car, he received the news of Suprava Sirkar’s demise. The demise of a long-time and close associate disturbed him. Even Bela’s and Sanat’s persuasion could not dissuade Hemanta from visiting Suprava Sirkar’s residence that day. The next day, 24th September, Hemanta’s album ‘Swaralahari’ was to be released at the Calcutta Press Club followed by his programme. In a little while after the cassette was released Hemanta felt unwell. Even after two days, when his health showed no signs of improvement, he was shifted to Belle Vue Clinic on the advice of the visiting cardiologist on 26th September 1989 late evening. He passed away at 11:15 pm in the nursing home. His legacy still lives on through the numerous songs he had rendered and composed. I would conclude my narrative with a Hymn from the Svetasvatara Upanishad rendered by Hemanta Kumar Mukhopadhyay. ‘Shrinwantu vishwe amritasya putra’ – these verses tell us that humans are not sinful creatures and can become immortal through their deeds, hence Amritasya putra… and the journey continues……..

26. Shrinwantu Vishwe Amritasya Putra, Hemanta Kumar Mukhpadhyay, film Alor Pipasa (1965)

As I come to the end of my my two-part tribute to Hemant Kumar,  let me summarise his total career as a singer and music director, including his film and non-film songs in Hindi, Bengali and other languages, both composed by him and other music directors.

Hemant Kumar’s total career at a glance

Hemant Kumar career table

Notes:
1. No figures are error free nor any information can be considered absolutely authentic. Often we have found that even information from the horse’s mouth can be wrong.
2. Data/ figures for Bengali film songs and non-film songs (both Bengali and Hindi) are not readily available.
3. I have tried to compile the figures to the best of my ability with reference to scattered information and data that I could trace out from different sources. I cannot vouch for the accuracy/ thoroughness of the information/ data.
4. For Hindi films the figures can be taken as relatively accurate, since sources like Har Mandir Singh ‘Hamraaz’ Saheb’s HFGK and the HFGM are available for reference, yet an allowance of (+/-) 2% may be considered.
5. I have consciously used Hemant Kumar’s name variously as Hemant/Hemant Kumar, or Hemanta/Hemanta Mukhopadhyay to signify the name he was popular as in Hindi or Bengali music respectively.

Acknowledgements & References:
1. Anandadhara (as told by Hemanta Mukhopadhyay) by Abhik Chattopadhyay; Saptarshi Prakashan, Kolkata (2013) – Published earlier by New Bengal Press Pvt. Ltd. 1975
2. Amaar Swami Hemanta: (as told by Bela Mukhopadhyay) by Partha Ghosh; Sahityam, Kolkata, 1999
3. V Shantaram: The Man Who Changed Indian Cinema by Madhura Pandit Jasraj, Hay House India, 2015
4. Lata Geet Kosh, Vol I, compiled and edited by Snehasis Chatterjee, Parul Prakashani 2008
5. List of songs & films: Compilation by Jaydeep Chakraborty; Assistance Sanjay Sengupta

Disclaimer:
The video links of the songs have been embedded from the YouTube/ Dailymotion only for the listening pleasure of the music lovers. This blog does not claim copyright over them which rests with the respective owners such as Saregama India Private Limited, Eros, Shemaroo and others.

{ 118 comments… read them below or add one }

1 S Joseph September 26, 2020 at 12:43 pm

Being the death anniversary of Hemant Kumar , the part 2 of ‘ HEMANTAYAN ‘ is presented timely . I would be lying if I say that I read the whole writeup so fast but on a mere glance through I must say that the songs selection is great. A lot of statistics has also been compiled for the benefit of all . After regular exposure to statistics at SOY, I feel something would be missing without some amount of statistics . All statistics compilation when the available data is not digitized is a lot of labour which I would never attempt. There is a lot of scope for compilation of statistics about songs and two such are about the sales and number of times played on radio channels. I think we should also declare the word count of any writeup. A great writeup which covers his work in Bengali and other languages . I join the SOY family to pay tributes to Hemant Kumar on this day .

One song…

‘ Jab jaag utthe …’ / 1963 / BIN BADAL BARSAAT / Shakeel / Hemant Kumar / Hemant

https://youtu.be/IhFZQOY4w5Q

2 Hans September 26, 2020 at 12:51 pm

Venkataramanji,

Great write up. I have gone through the earlier part and partly the Bengali films part. The reason is, I wanted to surprise everybody by being the first. Normally I dont enter at the start. I will give detailed comments later. One thing I want to point out is that when he entered into production in Hindi I had thought that he accepted lesser Hindi films and sung less songs in Hindi films to focus on production. Till then I did not know the amount of work he did in Bengali films. After your write up and summary of Bengali films, I am sure he deliberately moved from Hindi to Bengali, which was naturally his first love. For this he got the benefit from his reputation derived on the basis of Hindi films. I know my theory is in opposition to your theory that Hemant Kumar moved to Bengali and production, because of the squeezing space in Hindi films. But, after the stats of his Bengali work which show the enormous work he put out, I am confirmed in my opinion. This is like Mukesh himself opting to reduce playback singing for the sake of his career as actor. I would come up with other comments later. Thanks again for the great write-up and I wholly agree with AK, when he says in the intro that this is the most comprehensive write-up about Hemant Kumar and I am happy that SOY is the tool for that, because I have a great liking for him both as singer and composer, and also as a human being.

3 Hans September 26, 2020 at 12:53 pm

Oh! I missed again being the first by just 8 minutes and again lost out to Josephji.

4 ASHOK M VAISHNAV September 26, 2020 at 1:47 pm

N Venkataramanji’s two part Hemantayan has so masterfully turned out to be the macroscopic over view of Hemant Kumar’s career,. By delving into very meticulous details about his Bollywood association, NV has presented to us a ring side view of intricate corners of his career.

Thanks for so apt a centenary tribute to one of the most outstanding music director and singer of Hindi Film world.

I would add here a 1972 Gujarati NFS –
Tamara Ahi Aaj Pagal Thavana, Chaman MaN BadhaNe Khabar Padi Gai Chee
(Every one in this orchard knows that you have now gone mad. All branches and flowers have lowered their gaze; they feign modesty but, in effect that is the effect of your gaze.)

https://youtu.be/Z787iiXDxSM

5 N Venkataraman September 26, 2020 at 5:46 pm

Josephji @ 1,
Thank you for your prompt and appreciative response.

Some of the Hindi and Bengali songs were posted in the last post ‘ Hemant Kumar’s Male Playback singers’ and Hemantayan Part 1. I am glad that you like the selection of songs.

True, the compilation of statistics did entail a lot of labour. I tried to do it to the best of my ability and I am sure it can be improved further. I will not be modest in saying that even the write-up necessitated a lot effort and labour. Especially the Bengali part, I struggled to give it a definite meaningful shape.

Thanks for posting the solo ‘Jab Jaag Uthe Armaan’ from Bin Baadal barsaat (1963). That covers both the solos rendered by Hemant Kumar for this film.

Hope you will be back with your views after going through the article in entirety.

6 N Venkataraman September 26, 2020 at 5:47 pm

Hansji @ 2,

Thank you for your appreciative words and observation. I would wait for you to go through section 3, covering his career in Bengali films, before responding to your views on Hemant Kumar venturing into production and deliberately moving from Hindi to Bengali films.

7 N Venkataraman September 26, 2020 at 5:49 pm

Ashok Vaishnavji @ 4,
Thank you for your encouraging words.

I am happy that I could meet the expectations of senior SoY members like you and Hansji.

Indeed, Hemant Kumar was one of the most loved singer and musician even outside Bengal.

Thank you for posting the Gujarati NFS ‘Tamara Ahi Aaj Pagal Thavana, Chaman MaN BadhaNe Khabar Padi Gai Chee’ and also giving the meaning of the mukhda. I understand the record was released in 1972 (Record No. SEDE 3366) and the song was penned by Gani Dahiwala (mentioned by the uploader of the song in YT) and composed by Kirit Rawal. On the other side of the record were two songs a solo and a duet with Ranu Mukherjee.

Posting the solo by Hemant Kumar
O ghat ghatna antarayami , Gujarati NFS (1972), lyrics Bhaskar Vohra, music Kirit Rawal
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O8mx-p9uT6w

8 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty September 26, 2020 at 6:29 pm

N Venkatraman ji,

We tend to read long narratives narratives in bits and pieces. But, not this time! I am here after reading, absorbing, experiencing and enjoying every word of the superb write up.

What a brilliant work! Kudos, hats off, congratulations…. etc etc etc. You deserve all the accolades.

I would first mention Composer Kishore Kumar’s second song for Hemant Da.

Chalti chala jaa Zindagi ke dagar par..
….
Door ka rahi..

DOOR KA RAHI, 1971.
Shailendra.

Almost sounding like the continuation of Rahi tu mat rukh jaana , this , too, is the title song.

A small correction.

Marathi paavoola padthe pude has one more singer, another Mangeshkar sibling, Meena.
So, the song is Hemant Kumar with All the Mangeshkar siblings sans Asha.

Yes. As Anandghan ( cloud of joy ) Lata scored music for 4 Marathi movies between 1963 and 1969. Earlier, in 1950, as Lata Mangeshkar she had composed the music for RAM RAM PAVHANA where she had C Ramachandra singing a duet with Meena Mangeshkar. So, to my knowledge, these are the only 2 songs under her direction sung by Non Mangeshkars.

You can post the beautiful Marathi paavoola… for the listening pleasure of the readers.

Will keep coming back to comment on this superlative post.

9 Mehfil Mein Meri September 26, 2020 at 6:44 pm

Oh my God!
What a detailed post, packed with information. Hats off NVR ji. Great great job done.
I’m yet to listen to all the songs, but read the post completely. You have touched upon all the aspects of his career.
I agree with AK ji that such comprehensive posts on Hemant Kumar’s musical journey won’t be available on any other blog.
You are simply amazing.

Loved the posts. Thank you so much.
The posts can be referred to as a reference book.

Anup
🙂

10 N Venkataraman September 26, 2020 at 7:46 pm

AKji,
In fact I cannot thank you enough, for patiently going through the two lengthy articles, constantly interacting through e-mail, seeking clarifications and suggesting necessary changes, and doing the most important job of editing and making the article presentable. I should also thank you for your nice introductions to both the parts, brief and crisp, and for giving me the opportunity to present my tributes to Hemanta Mukhopadhyay on his centenary year.

Thank You Akji once again for everything.

11 Dr. Rajesh Deshpande September 26, 2020 at 8:25 pm

Venkataramanji,

What a great landmark post on Hemant Kumar!!
You have provided us a complete biography on the legendary personality, covering both the personal and professional aspects of his life along with all the milestones, achievements and statistics.
I got lot of new information from both the posts and more so, on his contributions to Bengali cinema and music..
Such an extensive detailed study would have required lot of efforts, research and verification on your part.
This is a wonderful material for someone doing a PhD on Hemant Kumar.

Glad to see couple of his Marathi songs in the post.
Mee dolkara dolkar dariya cha raja is an all-time classic.
Hemantda sang a limited number of Marathi songs, but almost all of them are well-known, popular and remembered till date.

Here’s the link to Marathi paool padte pudhe… from Maratha Tituka Melwawa
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ce4TKodXUFc

Here’s his evergreen duet with Asha from film Ha Khel Savlyancha
Gomu sangtina majhya tu yeshil kaay
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pbH8uMOzwjk

And a nice non-film romantic solo from 1972 – Preeti chya chand raati
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NX2buuEZAb0

12 Canasya September 27, 2020 at 12:16 am

Venkataraman ji:

Please accept thanks and salutations of a fan. You have excelled yourself, and in the process, set a new benchmark for SoY. The piecewise chronological account presented here in your racy style makes reading it a breeze. The main arguments are also compelling. Hemant Kumar was a singer, an MD and a producer in that order. A creative person to the core, I think it was a miracle he survived at all as a producer so long in the out and out commercial world of Bollywood. Let me illustrate this with an example.

Just as Hemant Kumar was part of Agradoot in Bengal, he was also part of United Producers (UP) in Bollywood, a producers’ collective comprising names such as Shakti Samant, Raj Khosla, Chetan Anand, Hrishikesh Mukherjee, K. A. Abbas, and others. It was UP which had organized the talent contest that discovered Rajesh Khanna. That was the reason Rajesh Khanna’s initial films were all with UP members. The commercially savvy among UP members were quick to encash his stardom by producing a series of films with him. For instance, Shakti Samant followed up his Aradhana with Kati Patang and Amar Prem in quick succession. Hemant Kumar failed to capitalize on whatever success Khamoshi had.

Here is ‘Hum chahe ya na chahe’ (Hemant in Phir Bhi, 1971; Raghunath Seth)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nw2GQFPHUSI&ab_channel=soshilmall

13 Subhasree Mitra September 27, 2020 at 3:55 am

Very consolidated biography in addition to nicely portrayed on various aspects on his great musical journey with multifaceted experience. Overall great narrative biography of our Bengal’s Musical Legendary personality.

14 AK September 27, 2020 at 6:14 am

Subhasree,
Welcome to Songs of Yore.

15 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty September 27, 2020 at 10:52 am

Before the superb ANUPAMA, 1966 , Hemant Da and Kaifi Azmi had DO DIL and FARAAR in 1965.

FARAAR.

Highly listenable..

Log peete hain, dagmagate hain
Dil se duniya ka gam mitathe hain…

Romantic..

Kaise bane dil ki baat haaye
Main bhi deewana, Dil bhi deewana…

16 Subodh Agrawal September 27, 2020 at 11:07 am

AK and Mr Venkataraman,

Hemant is my favourite singer, and the only reason I have not commented so far is that I was too absorbed in enjoying the music and the writing to think of commenting. Let me make up for this by thanking Mr Venkataraman for giving us so much amazingly high quality material on Hemant. The songs are familiar, but the writing helped me enjoy them better.

‘Yeh nayan dare dare’ is perhaps the iconic song of Hemant. The richness of his voice lends it a resonant gravity that no cover can match. Lata has tried a cover, but even someone as superlative as she comes nowhere near the original. I became aware of the original ‘Ei raat tomar amar’ much later.

Hope you wont stop with just two in the series. Please give us more.

17 G Viswanath September 27, 2020 at 11:25 am

Dear Raja,
Truly a phenomenal.undertaking on one of the stalwarts of popular Indian music. I am sure the industry national and Bengali in particular would appreciate your work.. You should look for opportunities in periodicals on a regular basis. To sum it up all: SPLENDID!

Best, Vishy

18 Ayan Banerjee September 27, 2020 at 5:40 pm

Gone through part 2 thoroughly . Very consistent write up in line with part 1. Again as I said earlier very unbiased write up too. Enjoyed reading. I was thinking reading this write up that Hemant kumar was an excellent risk taking modern day Business man . I think to be successful we must take risk come what may . Raja da ( N Venkataramana) good job done.

19 pkulkarni September 27, 2020 at 5:46 pm

dear sri venkatramanji,
have been Hemanda fan since i came out of movie BBB,1963. Have been waiting since the day HEMANTYAN -1. my wait was worth. THANKS & regards

20 AK September 27, 2020 at 6:21 pm

Mr P Kulkarni,
Welcome to Songs of Yore.

21 Jaideep Ghosh September 27, 2020 at 6:22 pm

Very detailed and balanced account. Touching on something that has been integrated into Bengali culture and psyche. My compliments.

22 N Venkataraman September 27, 2020 at 8:49 pm

Pradeepji @ 8,
My sincere thank for your appreciation.
Let me first give the link to the song, mentioned by you.

Chalti chala jaa Zindagi ke dagar par..
Door ka rahi..
DOOR KA RAHI, 1971.
Shailendra.
Almost sounding like the continuation of Rahi tu mat rukh jaana , this , too, is the title song.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ia-L6Bf45F8

I think, Hemant Kumar rendered two songs composed by Kishore Kumar in ‘Door Gagan Ki Chaon Mein’ (1964) and ‘Door Ka Raahi’ (1971).

‘Door Gagan Ki Chhaon Mein’ was Kishore Kumar’s debut as a director and Hemant Kumar lent his voice to the title song. ‘Anindita’ (1972) was the first and only Bengali movie directed by Hemanta, and Kishore Kumar lent his voice to the popular number ‘Ogo Nirupama’, lyrics Mukul Dutta.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WVpa0PJa3zE

Besides, Hemant Kumar scored music for seven films in which Kishore Kumar acted; four Hindi films and three Bengali films.
Hindi: Bandi (1957) – AshoK Kumar, Kishore Kumar and Anup Kumar, Miss Mary (1957), Girl Friend (1960) and Do Duni Chaar (1968).
Bengali: Lukochuri (1958) – Kishore Films, Ektuku Chhonwa lage (1965) and Dushtu Prajapati (1967).
And Hemanta play backed for Kishore Kumar in the Bengali film ‘Dushtu Prajapati’ released in 1967.
Posting the song ‘Sukh Namey Suk Pakhi ‘, lyrics Shyam Chakraborty
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w7vRe8YzkJ0

23 N Venkataraman September 27, 2020 at 9:09 pm

Pradeepji @ 8,
Thank you for the correction. I presume that Meena Mangeshkar sings in the children’s porting of the song ‘Marathi paavoola padthe pude ‘. Your wish has been fulfilled. Rajeshji has posted the link to the song. Thanks for the additional information on Lata Mangeshkar’s role as a composer.

24 N Venkataraman September 27, 2020 at 9:15 pm

@9’
Thank you Anupji.
Glad that you liked the post.
Please do listen to the songs and come back with your further comments/ songs.

25 AK September 27, 2020 at 9:24 pm

Mr Jaideep Ghosh,
Welcome to Songs of Yore.

26 Santanu September 27, 2020 at 9:57 pm

Raja

Normally I glance at stuff posted on the Internet and just skim through articles one-twentieth the length of Hemantayan-2. You had me read this whole lot at one sitting!

I get beads of sweat just thinking about the amount of patience and effort that went behind the creation of this remarkably absorbing narration!

Respect.

27 N Venkataraman September 27, 2020 at 9:58 pm

Rajeshji @ 11,
Thank you for your appreciation.
Yes, both the part did entail a lot of effort and study. It was indeed a privilege and I am happy that I could pay an apt tribute to the legendary musician Hemanta Mukhopadhyay on his centenary year. I should thank Akji for giving me the opportunity.

Thanks for the songs from ‘Maratha Tituka Melwawa’, ‘Ha Khel Savlyancha’ and the NFS.

Posting a Marathi devotional song (1969), Gouri Ganesha
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XLYRnFQN3KA

28 N Venkataraman September 27, 2020 at 10:42 pm

Canasyaji @ 12,
My heartfelt thanks for your generous appreciation.

I entirely agree with you that Hemant Kumar was singer first and then a composer and producer. His fans flocked to his program till his last program to listen to his singing. He stubbornly clung on to his obsession as a producer, which affected his health and career.

Thank you for sharing the information on United Producer’s collective and its role in Rajesh Khanna’s rise to stardom. I was not aware of this information. But there lies a difference between the collectives that operated in Bengal and UP. The collectives like Agradoot were a group of people/ technicians who signed and worked collectively as directors. I think the directors of the UP group did not work or sign as one single body in their directorial ventures.

Thanks for posting the solo fom Phir Bhi (1971).
There was also a nice duet with Ranu Mukherjee
Sanjh khale bhour dhale
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KhZXA-S6pOw

29 N Venkataraman September 27, 2020 at 10:50 pm

@13,
Thank you Subhasree Mitra for your encouraging response.

30 mumbaikar8 September 28, 2020 at 5:58 am

NV
I have discussed my obsession of multi-tasking, that makes it very difficult for me to read or write for a longer period.
Mr. Santanu’s comment is exactly what I would have said if I could.
So if I am not sued for plagiarism by Mr. Santanu I would like to copy and paste his comment, right from “Normally” to “narration”
Adding to it I would say I went through each and every song too.
Time well spent.

Most of the SOY family members are big fan of his voice. I for one was conditioned by the two voices I grew admiring and I do not have say who they are. So, to adulate HK voice like Shamshad Begum’s was and “still” is difficult.

I rank him very high in Music Directors and going through his Bengali songs it has climbed still higher.
He should have been more active in Hindi music direction too.
Tare bole deo of Dui bhai is my pick of the songs, he should have recycled it in Hindi.
The song I liked and was not ( I think )used in Hindi is
Khirki theke singha duar, from Stree.
The third is O nodi re that was used in Kohra
O beqarar dil
https://youtu.be/KxOGhSp1oEU

“Bengali listeners will certainly recognize the eminently popular tune of this song which was composed for the Bengali film ‘Monihaar’ (1966).”

Regarding this song I have an observation, correct me if I am wrong.
I think this song is inspired by SDB”s Jeevan Jyotis’s Tasveeren banti hai with Asha
https://youtu.be/jaIRZxfIKuU?t=65

31 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty September 28, 2020 at 11:15 am

Uttam Kumar’s playback singers in Hindi were Rafi ( CHHOTI SI MULAQAT ), Kishore Kumar ( AMANUSH, ANAND ASHRAM ) and Bhupinder Singh ( DOORIYAN ).

I don’t think he had any songs in KITAAB and DESH PREMEE .

Did Hemant Kumar sing for him?
Yes, in a much delayed movie , where, the titles say

And,
Above all,
Late Uttam Kumar.

Janani jagat ki Shakti O Mata
Bhakton ki jeevan ki bhakti O Mata…

MERA KARAM MERA DHARAM, 1987.
HK, Anuradha Paudwal; AB, LP.

Even DESH PREMEE was released after the death of UK.

32 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty September 28, 2020 at 11:57 am

Laxmikant Pyarelal, in their second movie, HARISCHANDRA TARAMATI, 1963, gave a beautiful song to Hemant Kumar.

Jagat bhar ke roshni ke liye
Karodon ki zindagi ke liye
Sooraj re, tu jalte rehna..

The background song plays twice in the movie….
With the titles first, and, then, when Raja Harischandra leaves Ayodhya, after giving all his wealth and possessions to Maharshi Vishwamitra.

There are 2 more BGSs in the movie..1 each by Rafi and Kavi Pradeep.

Meghva gagan beech jhaanke and Main ek chota as, Main ek nanna sa bachha hoon by Lata are good songs. But, by far, the HK song is my personal favorite. And, I know, ksbhatia Pa ji also likes this song very much.

33 N Venkataraman September 28, 2020 at 12:41 pm

Pradeepji @ 15,
The links to the songs from ‘Faraar’ (1965)
Both highly listenable songs
Log peete hain, dagmagate hain
Dil se duniya ka gam mitathe hain…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dRQ4u48yb8M

Kaise bane dil ki baat haaye
Main bhi deewana, Dil bhi deewana…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J53t2Y_xaXI&feature=emb_title

Kaifi Azmi also wrote the songs for ‘Kohra’ (1964) too.
Kaifi Azmi must have penned roughly 24 songs for these four films.
Hemanta rendered five solos in three of the films. For ‘Do Dil’ (1965) he did not give himself any song.
Out of the five songs four songs have been posted. One song from ‘Kohra’ remains to be posted.

Hemant Kumar rendered two more songs penned by Kaifi Azmi and composed by other music directors. One was duet. I am posting the solo for ‘Uski Kahani’ (1966). The music director was Kanu Roy. The song was based on a Rabindra Sangeet ‘Bhenge mor ghare Chabi niye jabi ke amare’ which was again a takeoff from a Bengali folk song (Baul), ‘Dekhechi rupsagore moner manush kacha sona’.

Hemant Kumar solo song ‘Tera Hai Jahaan Saara Apna Magar Tu Nahi Hai’, Uski Kahani (1966), lyrics Kaifi Azmi, music Kanu Roy
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LKdGisBIh-g

34 N Venkataraman September 28, 2020 at 12:47 pm

Subodhji @ 16,
Thank you for your encouraging words.
The two part series was quite lengthy and I am gratified that the SoY readers and my friends went through both the parts patiently and liked it. And I expect there would be at least one more article, on duets composed by Hemant Kumar, by Ashok Vaishnavji as part of the follow-up article.

He had a god gifted voice. ‘Yeh nayan dare dare’ and ‘Ei raat tomar amaar’ are both iconic songs.

‘Tum pukar lo’ is arguably the most haunting solos of Hemant Kumar. Tum pukar lo, is the song composed for the same situation, is considered to be an improvisation on the Bengali number ‘Ei raat tomar amaar’. Thus we have another great composition rendered by Hemant Kumar. Incidentally the tune of the song was used in the title credit of a TV Serial ‘Talash’ produced by Jayanta Mukherjee (Hemanta’s son) in 1992. I have posted the lyrics while concluding section two. Here is the link to the song rendered by Suresh Wadkar, lyrics Yogesh.
https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x2koeom

35 N Venkataraman September 28, 2020 at 12:55 pm

G Viswanath @ 17,
Thank you Vishwam for your response and nice words.
I am an accidental writer and looking for opportunities in periodicals on a regular basis is still a far cry for me.
Thank you for your wishes too.

36 N Venkataraman September 28, 2020 at 1:00 pm

Ayan @ 18,

Thanks for your considerate words. I also got your hint on ‘risk taking’.

37 N Venkataraman September 28, 2020 at 1:05 pm

Kukarniji @ 19,
Glad to find that there are so many Hemant Kumar admirers even today and outside Bengal too.
It was also worth my efforts that I could satisfy a die-hard Hemant Kumar fan.
Thanks a lot for your response.

38 N Venkataraman September 28, 2020 at 1:07 pm

Jaideep Ghosh @ 22,
Thanks a lot for you compliments.

39 N Venkataraman September 28, 2020 at 1:16 pm

Sanatanu @ 26,
That makes my day.
It is rewarding that my efforts haven’t gone to waste.
Thank You.

40 N Venkataraman September 28, 2020 at 4:44 pm

Mumbaikarji @ 30,

Thank you for the detailed response.
It is heartwarming to receive appreciation for the efforts put in.
And the appreciations and encouragements from my fellow SoYers like you and my friends provide me sustenance to move on. I was apprehensive that the Bengali Part may have few takers. Your response gladdens me.

‘Tare bole deo’ from ‘Dui Bhai’ and ‘Khirki theke singha duar’ from ‘Stree’ are very popular songs. The song ‘Khirki theke singha duar’ was composed by Dr. Nachiketa Ghosh for the film ‘Stree”. Yet Hemanta could have use it in one of his Hindi films, since we have found instance of Hemanta using Nachiketa Ghoshs’s 1958 NFS, ‘Meghla Bhanga Rod Utheche’ for the song ‘Phulwa band mehke’ in the film ‘Hum Bhi Insaan Hai’ (1959).

Yes the song ‘Nijhuma Sandhyay’ could have been inspired by the part ‘ Tasveere banti hai kirne si chhanti hai mere khyaalo mein aaj’ of the song posted by you. Even if it is an inspiration, Hemanta had retooled the it so very efficiently that he could produce another gem of a song and there are very few, who have a pair of sharp ears worth a few ‘Lakh Ashrafis’, who can trace out such similarities.

Paying my respects to the living legend Lata Mangeshkar’s on her 91st birthday let me post duet composed by Hemanta Mukherjee. There were two versions, both duets rendered by Hemanta and Lata. Posting both the versions.

Ke Jeno Go Dekeche Amay, lyrics Mukul Dutta, film Monihaar (1966)
This version comes first in the film,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZTxPyczHHMw

The second version, the song starts 06:03 of the following link
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5A6Z_Zn2Rfo

41 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty September 28, 2020 at 4:58 pm

SAMBANDH, 1969.

O P Nayyar’s only time with Hemant Kumar and Kavi Pradeep.

Solo..

1. Apni Mata ke dulare bachhe
Tujhpe qurban main pyare bachhe…

This stage song follows immediately the Mahinder Kapoor song
Kisi se ab mera koi rishta hai.

2. Duet with Mahinder Kapoor.

Jo diya tha tumne ek din mujhe phir woh pyar de do
Ek karz maangta hoon, bachpan udhar de do..

HK comes in with…
Tuhje dekh naachthe hain
Mere pichhle din woh suhane..

Both picturized on a sauve looking Pradeep Kumar. Deb Mukherjee is the hero.

Can’t resist pointing out 3 Pradeeps in this comment. ( A smiley needed here. )

42 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty September 28, 2020 at 5:25 pm

If I am not mistaken, HEERALAAL PANNALAAL , 1978, must be Hemant Kumar’s only film with RDB.

Aajaa mere pyar aajaa
Ab toh raha na jaaye…

Asha Bhosle chips in with ‘ Papa ‘, some laughter etc.

Picturized on Papa Premnath ( in his younger avatar ) and the child artiste playing Daughter Zeenat Aman’s younger self.

There is a RDB, Asha version on Amjad Khan and ( adult ) Zeenat. Premnath ( older ), in weird get up, is in the audience, tortured to see his daughter perform an ‘ item number’ ( though it was called a club dance , then. ) Papa has visions of his own song ( video only, no audio ) while this one is in progress.

Catchy tune well sung by HK, I should say.

43 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty September 28, 2020 at 6:14 pm

I am wrong about RDB _ HK.

CHOR HO TO AISA, 1978.

Masthi mein bait ke lagao oonche udaan
Arre, Shiv ji ke naam leke Lala,
Pee jaao re bhang!
( Dangerous in the present scenario!)

With Asha Bhosle, Kishore Kumar; Majrooh.

Picturized on Pran, it has a little Yaari hai imaan mera.. hangover!

44 Dr. Rajesh Deshpande September 28, 2020 at 7:59 pm

Hemantda sang 2 songs for film Aadarsh 1983, written and composed by Drishtant Thakral
Must be a home production as Drishtant was the hero of the film too.

One solo – Us paar se dheere dheere

And one duet with Aparna Mayekar
Jab dil deewana ho jaaye

Here’s the link to the duet:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sVLdDSndxcA

45 Dr. Rajesh Deshpande September 28, 2020 at 8:09 pm

Dr. Shetty @42, 43

Here’ are the links to the songs posted by you:
Heeralal Pannalal
Aaja mere pyar aaja

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KjJ7oWDtbjA

Chor Ho To Aisa
Masti mein baith ke lagao oonchi udaan

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TCDwPwFiCqo

46 Hans September 29, 2020 at 12:07 am

Venkataramanji,

I have gone through your article and also listened some songs partly and some fully. 4/5 of the Bangla songs are really very good. The recital from Upanishad at the end was just wonderful. I also quickly went through Hemantayan-1. You have told almost the whole story of HK, which a reader may like to know. I had earlier a great regard for him as a person. But, your narrative of how he was all for the family and the in-laws family has raised him further in my eyes. It was his customary love for the home turf, which Bengalis generally have, which took him to settle back in Calcutta. Many of the Bengali MDs who made good in Bombay, did not return like he did. The Bengali public paid back in kind the love he showed for home land. Your narrative makes it clear that after the success in Bombay, he immediately grabbed the opportunities he got in Calcutta.

Your narration of his last days shows how he loved being in public and how it drained as well as sustained him. I think his absolutely crazy travelling combined with his excessive smoking proved an undoing. Overwork I will not give as a cause, because music was his life, but, the worries of production and the series of failures might have taken their toll.

I still hold the view that he himself became selective in the Hindi world, to shift to his home ground, where he had more natural surroundings and he was always among the top composers. Whereas in Hindi, he was just an also ran in the big sea. The example of Hans Raj Behl is there, who chose Panjabi films where he was king.

One thing is also clear from your stats that in Bengali films he had a big percentage of solos, which he was not having in Bombay. I think, despite the fact that he sang some great duets, his first love was for solos. He himself composed some great solos not only for himself, but also for others in Hindi films. The fact, that he sang about 10 times the number of NFS in Bangla than Hindi, is also indicative of his preference for solos as well as his desire to keep close to his home turf.

I think the song from Rahgeer, ‘janam se hoon banjara’ you put in at No. 4 pretty sums up his life philosophy. There was a song in two parts in Sambandh, in which in the first part Mahendra Kapoor sings for Deb Mukherjee ‘ab to shamshaan ki mati hi meri mata hai’ to which Pradeep Kumar replies in the voice of Hemant Kumar ‘ab to is desh ki maati hi teri mata hai’. I think the second part fits the return of HK to his home and the first part fits to his death. I am giving the link to the second part.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5dw3xJP51H4

There is one request to make. Since I came late in Hemantayan 2, I could not post songs there. So can I post a few songs from the period upto 1960, if not posted earlier. This may not violate the scheme of things because both parts have already been posted.

47 AK September 29, 2020 at 7:47 am

Hans,
Before Venkataramanji responds to you I couldn’t help myself coming in. Thanks a lot for your very perceptive comments, this is the kind of comment any writer craves for. You have not only read the two parts, you have also grasped the essence of the Hemant Kumar as a person and an artiste.

As for your last query, my own preference would be that you post pre-60 songs in Part-1. As for SOY regulars, we have read the articles in sequence, therefore for us, it would be quite all right if you post here. But for someone who lands up through Google search or otherwise, or after some months or years each post is standalone by itself. For her it would be appropriate that post-specific comments are posted there.

But I leave the choice to you. Even if you post on earlier posts, regular readers get a notification.

48 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty September 29, 2020 at 9:37 am

HK with LP.

Majrooh Sultanpuri.

Bhor bai uth jaag re bande
Rain gayi ab sona pyare…

MERE LAL, 1966.

49 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty September 29, 2020 at 12:05 pm

All B R Chopra productions, starting with their first, EK HI RASTA, 1956, start with Hemant Kumar’s recital of
Karmanye vadikaraste.. From Bhagavad-Geeta.

HK, himself, was the composer for EK HI RASTA.
Earlier, he had sung a couple of songs in SHOLE, 1953, B R Chopra’s second film as a director. Jaadugar Bhagwan anokha…, the multiple versions song was quite popular.

DASTAAN, 1972, BRC’s second film with Dilip Kumar, after the mega successful NAYA DAUR, 1957, was the remake of BRC’s first directorial venture, AFSANA, 1951. I S Johar is credited for the story of both the movies. In the second, he was among the star cast, too.

DASTAAN, with music by LP, ends with a couplet by Hemant Kumar.

Jaisa karam kare hai koi
Waisa hi phal paaye hain,
Narak kaho ya swarg kaho
Sab iss jag mein mil jaate hain…

And, then, the titles…
And love lives forever.

With this , I think I covered all the 4 instances of HK _ LP combination.

50 S Joseph September 29, 2020 at 2:58 pm

Another HK song that was very popular . This movie had other Male voice songs but HK was picked up only for this song . Naushad like most of our great MDs knew whose voice would suit a particular situation . Looking back it is difficult to imagine if anyone else of that era could fit in this situation …

‘ Insaaf ki dagar…/ 1961 / GANGA JAMUNA / Shakeel / Naushad / Hemant

https://youtu.be/OKT2ZNHBVfs

51 N Venkataraman September 29, 2020 at 5:55 pm

Pradeepji,
Before I provide the link to the songs mentioned by you, I would post a song which was penned by Kaifi Azmi for the Bengali film Monihaar (1966). I missed this song/film while discussing Hemant Kumar-Kaifi Azmi films @ 33. This is an interesting song. Hemanta composed this song for his idol Pankaj Mullick, picturised on Pahadi Sanyal.

Here the link
Piya Bin Nishi Din by Pankaj Mullick, film Monihaar (1966), lyrics Kaifi Azmi
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D9qJfiHLNvE

52 N Venkataraman September 29, 2020 at 5:56 pm

Pradeepji @ 31,
Uttam Kumar acted in 8 Hindi films. You have mentioned 7 films.
Plot No. 5 (1981) was released after his death. Here too Uttam kumar did not have any song.

@32,
The links to the songs mentioned by you

Janani jagat ki Shakti O Mata
Bhakton ki jeevan ki bhakti O Mata…
MERA KARAM MERA DHARAM, 1987.
HK, Anuradha Paudwal; AB, LP.

Probably this was the last Hindi film song rendered by Hemant Kumar, lip-synced by Abhi Bhattacharya
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r-ED6Y8AA2Y

Laxmikant Pyarelal, in their second movie, HARISCHANDRA TARAMATI, 1963, gave a beautiful song to Hemant Kumar. LYRICS KAVI PRADEEP
Jagat bhar ke roshni ke liye
Karodon ki zindagi ke liye
Sooraj re, tu jalte rehna..

The background song plays twice in the movie….
With the titles first, and, then, when Raja Harischandra leaves Ayodhya, after giving all his wealth and possessions to Maharshi Vishwamitra.
Providing the link with both the versions
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KPd1UregTZk&feature=emb_title

@ 41,

SAMBANDH, 1969.
O P Nayyar’s only time with Hemant Kumar and Kavi Pradeep.
Yes, Sambandh the only film where O P Nayyar gave Hemant Kumar some songs.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5dw3xJP51H4&feature=emb_title

Solo..
1. Apni Mata ke dulare bachhe
Tujhpe qurban main pyare bachhe…
This stage song follows immediately the Mahinder Kapoor song
Kisi se ab mera koi rishta hai.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5dw3xJP51H4&feature=emb_title

Please, you can post HK-MK duet in the next article on duets composed by Hemant Kumar.

53 N Venkataraman September 29, 2020 at 5:57 pm

Pradeepji,

Sharing a trivia.
Hemant Kumar’s son Jayanta Mukherjee’s first production venture was ‘Mazaq’ 1975. When Jayanta requested his father to score music for the film, Hemant Kumar told Jayanta that his name will not fetch a good price from the distributors and took him to R D Burman and requested RD to score music for the film. Even he refused to lend his voice and on persuasion from RDB and Jayanta he sang two lines just before the title credits invoking Lord Mahavir (Hanuman). You will find the two lines from 00:14 to 00:28 of the following link.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zd5JFXLkpQs

@ 42 & 43,

Thank you for posting the songs Hemant Kumar rendered for R D Burman.

HEERALAAL PANNALAAL , 1978, must be Hemant Kumar’s only film with RDB.
Aajaa mere pyar aajaa
Ab toh raha na jaaye…
Asha Bhosle chips in with ‘ Papa ‘, some laughter etc.

Probably the whole song was used in the film.

Aaja Mere Pyar Aaja (Part1 (1:00)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OS0YvXQudng
Part 2 (1:04)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OlMlOJ6hIdI
The link to the audio version of the entire song and the other song from ‘Chor Hoto Aisa’ are posted by Rajeshji @ 45.
Thanks Rajeshji.

54 N Venkataraman September 29, 2020 at 5:58 pm

Rajeshji @ 44,

Thanks for the songs from Aadarsh.
Here is the audio link to the Higly listenable solo, ‘Us Paar Se Dheere Dheere’ from Aadarsh (1983)
https://gaana.com/song/us-paar-se-dheere-dheere?autoplay=true

In comparison Hemant Kumar seems to be under strain in the duet.

55 N Venkataraman September 29, 2020 at 5:59 pm

Hansji @ 46,
I am falling short of words to express my profound gratitude and regards to you and also to all those who have taken the pain and effort to go through the two too-long articles and found it worth reading. I would simply like to echo AKji’s words.

‘You have not only read the two parts, you have also grasped the essence of the Hemant Kumar as a person and an artiste.’
Very aptly put. Such responses will just make my day. Thanks Hansji also for listening to the songs, especially the Bengali songs.

And you have correctly assessed the reason for his anxieties, worries and health problems. You hit the nail on the head when you said that after the success in Bombay, he immediately grabbed the opportunities he got in Calcutta. And that was a crucial decision. You philosophical projection of the songs from ‘Sambandh’ to drive home your point is interesting and impressive too.

‘I still hold the view that he himself became selective in the Hindi world, to shift to his home ground, where he had more natural surroundings and he was always among the top composers. Whereas in Hindi, he was just an also ran in the big sea. The example of Hans Raj Behl is there, who chose Panjabi films where he was king.’

No arguments on the second part.
True, Bengali language and films were naturally his first love. Yes, Hemanta says with conviction that he was very comfortable working in Bengali films since it was his home ground. His early literary background helped him in this regard. He had the habit of suggesting the mukhda of the songs he composed music for, upon which the songwriters penned the rest of the song. He had an excellent rapport and relation with his songwriters too. And when the opportunity came to score music in Bengali films came his way he jumped on to it.

But he was equally eager to find his foothold back in Hindi films. Hemant Kumar himself says in his biography that in last part of 59 and in the year 60, he did not have any work in hand in Bombay, and wanted to return to Calcutta. Reluctance of his family forced him to stay back. He clearly states that had the offer from Guru Dutt came a few months earlier, he would not have entered into production. Even after Bees Saal Baad and Sahib Bibi aur Ghulam , he got only one offer. The success of Bees Saal Baad and dearth of work in Bombay made him go for his second production venture. And the decision turned out to be his nemesis.

Hemant Kumar did not specifically mention that he restricted his Hindi films (after the failure Kohra) to concentrate on his in house-ventures or otherwise. Thus it leaves some space for speculation. We may have a point to ponder. And you can have your view.

I would conclude my extended discourse with a few words about Hemant Kumar as a principled and kind hearted person. Throughout he was very particular about paying back his debts in time. According to his son-in-law, Gautam Mukherjee, before Hemant Kumar was shifted to Belle view nursing home he directed his him to return back the advance money he had taken for his future programs and assignments, all put in separate envelopes with details written on it. There was also a separate envelope containing instruction to send money to a few people whom he had been silently supporting for quite some time.

And Akji has replied to your last part of your question. You are most welcome to post the songs here or in part 1 as per your wish. My only request to you and also to other SoY members/ readers would be to reserve the duets composed by Hemant Kumar for the next post to follow on the subject by Ashok Vaishnavji. Else you may post any song rendered and/ or composed by Hemant Kumar.

Thank you once again Hansji.

56 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty September 29, 2020 at 6:00 pm

In 1964, the year of KOHRA and the evergreen Ye nayan dare dare.. Biswajit once again sang in praise of Waheeda Rehman’s eyes in Hemant Kumar’s voice.

Tumhe jo bhi dekh lega
Kisi ka na ho sakega.
Pari ho? Bhala ho?
Kya ho tum?

….
Kajrare nain bhanwre
Palke jo kholte hain
Dilon ki bhi baat kya hai
Imaan bhi dolta hai…

MAJBOOR.

Indeevar ; Kalyanji Anandji ( Assistants _ LP.)

In the movie, KA used Rafi for a solo and Mahinder Kapoor for a duet on Biswajeet.

57 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty September 29, 2020 at 6:14 pm

Janmabhoomi Maa
Main yahan tu wahan
Tujhse door jaa raha
Main jaane kahan…

HK with Sabita Chowdhury’s vocal support; Kavi Pradeep, Salil Chowdhury.

NETAJI SUBHASHCHANDRA BOSE, 1966.

Slightly reminds of
Ae mere pyare watan.

58 ksbhatia September 30, 2020 at 1:19 pm

N. Venkatraman ji;

Joining late after thorough reading of mega and majestic article …nay…Library of Hemant da ‘s life and times …. that now we have the big and bold picture of this great Composer and Singer. Facts and Figures combined to give Faith that we all now getting enriched.!!.

There is strange comfort in knowing that no matter what happens today, Hemant Kumar believed in the Sun to rise again tomorrow. The strugglers always looks forword recalling …Good old days. Hemant really stood many trials but never losing his identity of calmpose and cool person. Hans ji very well summed up his life quoting song …janam janam se banjara hun re bandhu. I will add a line or two from his songs too……Mili chaman ko bahar khushi phool ko mili , geet koyal ko mele aur meine payi khamoshi . A song that fits in his life as he lived.

This popular song very emotional in content he sang in bengali in Sidhartha too .

O Nodi Re – Hemanta Kumar Mukhopadhyay – Siddhartha (1972)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hHmD8E9nj_8&t=109s

Of many songs I consider Hemant’s best for Salil Da’s song from Kabuliwala….Ganga aye kahan se …..that you already covered in your listed songs. every stanza conveys beautiful down to earth meanings. Faith gets activated as we listen to such divine voice that Hemant Kumar possesed. Those who achieve the extraordinary are usually the most ordinary and cool persons. Passion for Hemant was never half way….he continued his journey giving best to both worlds…Bombay and Calcutta !

59 ksbhatia September 30, 2020 at 1:38 pm

Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty @32;

Yes you quoted me right. The song …

Jagat bhar ke roshni ke liye
Karodon ki zindagi ke liye
Sooraj re, tu jalte rehna

is one of my favorite song , very meaningful indeed. This song I posted in many group during recent Solar Eclipse . Gospel songs takes me to another world .

60 ksbhatia September 30, 2020 at 3:02 pm

N. Venkatraman ji;

Over the centuries…I Love You…has been the most poetic expression when two lovers woos together . Hemants voice fitted very well in such romantic songs too.

While song from Jaal is too famous in era when lyrics were romantic and melody was queen. Hemant continued this romantic touch in a duet with Nutan in Chhabili ….a home production of Nutan family.

Lehron pe lehar…..Hemant, nutan….Chhabili [1960]….Snehal Bhatkar…

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HBm2otOgoHA

Snehal bhatkar made a fine version of this famous song ….Man who plays the mandolino’ .

Aye mere humsafar rok apni nazar ……was another beautiful romantic song sung by Nutan in that film .

61 N Venkataraman September 30, 2020 at 4:21 pm

Pradeepji @ 48,

HK with LP.
Majrooh Sultanpuri.
Bhor bai uth jaag re bande
Rain gayi ab sona pyare…
MERE LAL, 1966.
A short piece,
Link to the song
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LFLZ-sOJfm8

@49
DASTAAN, with music by LP, ends with a couplet by Hemant Kumar.
Jaisa karam kare hai koi
Waisa hi phal paaye hain,
Narak kaho ya swarg kaho
Sab iss jag mein mil jaate hain…
Is there any link available? I could not find any.

62 N Venkataraman September 30, 2020 at 4:34 pm

Josephji @ 50,
Thank you for posting the song from Ganga Jamuna (1961).
Hemant Kumar sang for Naushad only on two occasions.
The two versions (or is it three) of Chandan Ka Palna from Shabab (1954), a superb composition by Naushad, was posted by Pradeepji in the previous part.

I think Hemant Kumar also rendered four version / cover songs composed by Naushad.
Two from Sazaa (1951) and two from Aan (1952).

An unused song in the voice of Hemant Kumar probably recorded in the 60s.
I am not sure I might have posted it an earlier article.

Main Naiyya Tu Hai Mera Majhi , lyrics Prem Dhawan, music Ravi
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pq_nv5AAdeU

63 N Venkataraman September 30, 2020 at 4:35 pm

Pradeepji @ 56
MAJBOOR (1964)
Indeevar ; Kalyanji Anandji ( Assistants _ LP.)

Tumhe jo bhi dekh lega
Kisi ka na ho sakega.
Pari ho? Bhala ho?
Kya ho tum?
….
Kajrare nain bhanwre
Palke jo kholte hain
Dilon ki bhi baat kya hai
Imaan bhi dolta hai…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wmL2_-63oPc

@57
Sabita Chowdhury voice is use for harmonizing.
So the song may be accepted as a solo.

NETAJI SUBHASHCHANDRA BOSE, 1966, Salil Choudhury, Kavi Pradeep
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VZerR8rkbWs

64 N Venkataraman September 30, 2020 at 4:39 pm

Bhatiaji @ 58, 60
Welcome Bhatiaji. Thank you for your insightful comments. It gladdens me know that you gave a thorough reading of the article. Appreciation from SoY seniors like you are very special. You have aptly summed Hemant kumar’s never-say-die attitude in his life and career.

Yes, the song ‘O Nodi re’ has a universal appeal.
Thank you for posting ‘Lehron pe lehar’ A nice lovely duet.

Please listen to a vintage Hemant Kumar NFS
O Preet Nibhanewali (1943), lyrics Faiyaz Hashmi, music Kamal Dasgupta
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=veRHxpTvvMU

65 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty September 30, 2020 at 7:24 pm

NV ji,

Your trivia on Jayant reminds me of another interesting trivia.

In FERRY, 1954, in the song Na ro ae ronewale , Geeta Dutt, Dev Anand is shown playing violin.

In the movie, there is a sequence of jugalbandi of Sitar and Sarod between Dev Anand and Geeta Bali. The instruments are played by Pandit Nikhil Bannerjee and Ustad Ali Akbar Khan, respectively. ( Credited in the titles. )There is a boy seen playing tabla. Supposed to be Jayant Mukherjee.
But, the credits show Introducing Master Babu. One and the same?

66 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty September 30, 2020 at 7:45 pm

Insano ne paise ke liye
Aapas ka pyar mita daala…

PAISA YA PYAR , 1969.

Sahir, Ravi.

67 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty September 30, 2020 at 9:29 pm

The 1992 tele serial TALAASH produced by Jayanta Mukherjee and Mudratech, starring Alok Nath, Beena, Vijendra Ghatge , Dina Pathak and Moushumi Chatterjee, based on the novel SONAR KATHI RUPOR KATHI by Ashuthosh Mukherjee , lists Late Hemanta Mukherjee as music director.

The title song by Suresh Wadkar ( lyrics _ Yogesh )…
Jeevan ek pyaas hai
Sabhi ko kuchh talash hai..
is set to the tune of
Tum pukaar lo, KHAMOSHI.

68 Dr. Rajesh Deshpande September 30, 2020 at 10:32 pm

Venkataramanji @52. Dr. Shetty @31

Uttam Kumar acted in one more Hindi film called Bandie in 1978. He had a double role in it.
Alo Sircar was the director , Shyamal Mitra the MD and Sulakshana Pandit as the heroine. There was a Bengali version too.

Mera Karam Mera Dharam was originally titled Daawedaar. It was completed and certified in 1982 in the same name, but was never released.
In 1987, it was recertified as Mera Karam Mera Dharam and released.
I believe, the new title resembled the titles of Dharmendra’s action movies which helped it have a theatrical release.

Plot No, 5 1981 was an enjoyable suspense film, with no songs.

69 ksbhatia September 30, 2020 at 10:45 pm

N Venkataraman ji @64;

Beautiful NFS song….O Preet Nibhanewali (1943)…you have posted . Very much in the league of Pankaj Malik songs. Music by Kamal Dasgupta for this and other NFS songs are listener delights. The prelude of the song reminds me of mukhda of famous song….Na shikwa hai koi…of Tu Pyar kare ya thukra ye . This is my personal observation…lets see other endorse too.

Lyrics writer Faiyaz Hashmi is one of the most lovable song writer of Bengal sector . At one point of time Hemant kumar songs written by Faiyaz were very popular in eastern sector and in fact Hemant Kumar and Faiyad Hashmi rendered a song for a film ….Humsafar…made in East Pakistan….some time around 1960 ….much earlier than the birth of Bangla Desh. As always the song was a hit …and here is the song….

Film Humsafar …..Raat suhani hai …..Hemant Kumar

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y2xuBrZudmU

70 Dr. Rajesh Deshpande September 30, 2020 at 10:59 pm

An unusual song by Hemant Kumar for C. Ramchandra in film Bahurani 1963 ( lyrics – Sahir)
Eetal ke ghal mein teetal baahal achha ke bheetal.

He sings for the hero (Guru Dutt) who is mentally still a child, lisps while talking and plays with toys.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uEuQFuTcUS0

Usually, Kishore Kumar can be an apt choice for such a song.

But Hemant Kumar has sung quite well. His voice actually suited Guru Dutt here and he also had a duet with Lata in the film.

71 ksbhatia September 30, 2020 at 11:05 pm

N Venkataraman ji , Hans ji;

I think there are a few songs that got missed the Bus of pre 60s . Lyrical Gems of songs takes time to over board the bus or flights….but in their longer time period they leave the impression for many decades .

A gem that is close to my heart will surely find a place in many hearts…a melody par excellence….

Phir Wohi Naghma Suna De …..Hemant Kumar…. Shahi bazar 1957….Dhaniram [MD]..

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e1FDsZGgCkE

72 ksbhatia September 30, 2020 at 11:27 pm

N Venkataraman ji , Hans ji;

Those who wish to sing always finds a song . And those who wants tu huum along always finds heart to whisper along. Hemant da became popular in romantic songs with his low whisper toned voice matching the mood .

A duet with Lata ji beautifully composed by KA ….

Itna To Kah Do Humse | Lata Mangeshkar, Hemant Kumar | Saheli

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7zsrNNhMcDo

73 ksbhatia September 30, 2020 at 11:39 pm

In continuation ….

Another masterpiece with fine interludes…a speciality of Roshan duets…

chhupa lo dil mein yun pyar mera..Hemant Kumar-Lata -Majrooh -Roshanlal -Mamta 1966

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GXgKgZt9Jik&t=15s

74 N Venkataraman October 1, 2020 at 8:12 pm

Pradeepji @ 65,

Yes, Master Babu and Jayanta Mukherjee are one and the same.
Hemen Gupta’s daughter, Jayshree was credited as Baby Bula. Even their household pet dog ‘Sardar’ had a role in the film and was credited as ‘Lassie.

Adding another trivia. When Hemen Gupta came to Bombay, initially he put up with his family on rented ground floor flat at ‘Roop Kala’, on the 16th Road, Khar. The land lady of the house, who stayed at the first floor, was keen on a role in Hemen Gupta’s next film. She and her daughter (hardly an year old) had minor roles in Anand Math. And the toddler was none other than Daisy Irani.

Hemanta Mukherjee was the music director for the five, out of dozen films directed by Hemen Gupta. 3 Bengali Films and two Hindi films. Besides Hemanta sang five songs in two other films directed by Hemen Gupta for which Salil Chowdhury was the music director- ‘Kabuliwala’ (1961) and ‘Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose’ (1966).

Hemen Gupta could not complete his Bengali film ‘Anamika’ due to his untimely death in 1967. Hemanta Mukherjee was the music director for the film. I could not locate any of the (few) songs, believed to be recorded for the film.

75 N Venkataraman October 1, 2020 at 8:14 pm

Pradeepji,
Posting the song mentioned by you @ 66,
Insano ne paise ke liye
Aapas ka pyar mita daala…
PAISA YA PYAR, 1969.
Sahir, Ravi.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8j3qtjpUWrw

This reminds me of another song on the same theme,
Paise Ke Kya Kehne Ho Paisa Peer Hai, Ghulam Begum Badshah (1956), lyrics Shyam Hindi, music Sudipt
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=70-0ZDUkbLQ&feature=emb_title

@67,
Yes I remember watching this serial.
I have mentioned the lyrics of this song while concluding section one of this part and I have posted the song @ 34.

76 N Venkataraman October 1, 2020 at 8:15 pm

Rajeshji @ 68 & 70,
I missed out Bandhie (1978). Yes, you are right there was a Bengali version too. I think it was Alo Sirkar’s second film as a director and like the previous film Chhoti Si Mulaqaat (1967) , another Uttam Kumar starrer, this film also flopped.

Thank for the information on ‘Dawedaar’ and the posting the song from Bahruraani (1963).

Hemant Kuamr also rendered a nice duet with Lata Mangeshakar in this film.
Umr Hui Tumse Mile, lyrics Sahir Ludhyanvi
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PIUtQ30EaAw

The film was based on a Bengali novel ‘Swayamsiddha’ written by Manilal Banerjee. Between 1955 and 1998 there were atleast 11 films were made based on this novel.

77 N Venkataraman October 1, 2020 at 8:16 pm

Bhatiaji @ 69,71,72,73

O Preet Nibhanewali (1943) is typical vintage song and I could find the influences of Pankaj Mullick and Saigal too at some places. Experts may confirm .

I was unaware of the song ‘Raat suhani hai’ from the East Pakistan film of the 60s, ‘Humsafar.
And I was aware the song from Sahi Bazar (1957) but could not locate the link. A great addition.
Thank you for posting both the songs.

It appears that there were two more songs rendered by Hemant Kumar for this film. If so, can you or somebody find the links to the songs?

Thanks for the postings from ‘Saheli’ and ‘Mamta’

A NF solo composed and rendered by Hemant Kumar recorded in 1946 lyrics Faiyaz Hasmi
Aye Shaam Ki Hawaon
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uItPJnR1c3o

78 Hans October 1, 2020 at 8:28 pm

AK, @ 47

Thanks for the nice words. This subject of love for one’s home land is very close to my heart. I myself got some good opportunities to settle in Delhi while I was in service. But, I was of the firm view that I would not make that a permanent settlement. I know a few Bengalis who sacrificed a lot for the love of the home land. So I could understand HK’s desire to go back. As an artiste also I have been following him for a long time. I am sure if readers here listen to lesser known songs composed by him, they would also think anew about him.

I would like to post the songs here, because there are a lot of comments in Hemantayan-1 and whoever reads it in future would certainly read both parts as they are linked.

79 Hans October 1, 2020 at 10:18 pm

Venkataramanji, @ 55

Thanks for the nice words. I think every one should go through the two articles, which are great from every point of view, if not yet done. Songs is a choice. Bengali songs I can make out part meanings and Bengali music is, I think everyone’s favourite.

You write that he had the habit of suggesting mukhdas for songs. I have never seen it written about him earlier. It is not clear whether you are talking about Bengali songs only or Hindi songs too. His literary background was for Bengali, but that would hardly come handy for Hindi films. Occasional suggestions is OK, but no lyricist of some standard would like to write on dotted lines. It has always been said that lyricists wrote to tune in bollywood. If they were told the mukhda also then where was the need of the lyricist. I would not like to believe that even for Bengali lyricists, whatever be the literary background of HK.

You talk about his having paucity of work which forced him to enter production. You must be remembering that I did not agree to Kelkarji’s assertion, on the basis of what he was told by OPN, that he was not having work. I said that OPN tried to copy Naushad and limited his number of films. Hemant Kumar was soundly criticised (not initially but later) – more at home front – for entering into production. So it was natural that he would defend that decision in his biography. What you have written makes it clear that he was contemplating production from a much earlier date and in fact his first production in Bengali came in 1959. Its success encouraged him for a Hindi film. Production needed a lot of time, so he could not go at the same pace both in Bengali and Hindi films in the matter of composing. So he became choosy in Hindi films about which he thought that he had been reckless in doing too many films. Biswajeet was already a star in Bengali films and wanted to succeed in Bombay. Bees Saal Baad was the result of this and it was quite possible that Biswajeet also put some money in the film. The cast was not costly. For songs only Lata was as the other singer. So the huge success brought a lot of money with little cost. Who will not go for a second film in such circumstances. But, repeating everything from cast to singers, without some common success formula is risky and he suffered. I would say his going into production was well thought out and deliberate and continuing with it was also deliberate. Everybody becomes wiser in hindsight.

I think him to be one of the nicest fellows, who hated harming others and he was successful in his life and achieved a lot.

80 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty October 2, 2020 at 12:02 pm

AAG, 1967.

Ae Nari, issi liye hi duniya mein aayee tu,
Amrit aanchal se pilaye,
Aankhon se piye aansoo..

Asad Bhopali or Indivar; Usha Khanna.

Hemant Kumar’s only song with UK.

81 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty October 2, 2020 at 12:04 pm

Probably .. Should be added to my last sentence above.

82 ksbhatia October 2, 2020 at 3:34 pm

N Venkataraman ji;

Folk music and songs have always fascinated me. Folk music is really roots of culture. It is definitely closest to humanity with no strings attached …favorable to poor and rich too. While on my posting to Assam i had great time listening to Bengali and Assamese songs. The music accompanying the live Bihu dance I used to enjoy during non flood season. There were other events where locals used to invite us to enjoy such folk richness of Bengal and other north east states.

The folk song that ruled my house and found favorite of my daughters singing both bengali and hindi version was….dhinak dhinak bole. They sang this song while appearing in a certificate course of Ghandarv Maha vidyale ….and got thru with nice merit .

Here is a recall of that song beautifully sung by Lata ji and Hemant kumar with music by Salil da…..

dil tere liye dole,dhitang dhitang bole..Lata_Hemant Kumar_Prem Dhawan_Salil Chaudhary.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r8Bs-H49NEk&list=RDr8Bs-H49NEk&start_radio=1

83 Dr. Rajesh Deshpande October 2, 2020 at 8:34 pm

Hemant Kumar and Shammi Kapoor – an unusual combination!!

Bluff Master 1963
MD – Kalyanji Anandji

Aye dil ab kahin le jaa

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=znNJoXP25BY

84 Hans October 3, 2020 at 11:27 am

When I looked for the songs posted in Hemantayan-1 which were composed by HK, I found that they are very few. Venkataramanji posted 8 songs and not many followed. I think songs sung by him have been well covered on SOY, but from composition angle the discussions have not been happening. I posted a few songs from Samrat and Shart in Vaishnavji’s article on his female singers, which showed how some beautiful compositions were not much noticed because they did not become popular. Songs from Bhagwat Mahima also fall in that category. If one compares SDB composed Radha Krishna-1954 and this film – which are in the same genre – HK compositions are far superior. Some of the songs were very popular initially.

First I put up two songs in his own voice, with the usual magic of his voice.
‘Bhagwat bhagwan ki hai aarti’ was a popular song in its times and I have heard it on Radio quite a number of times.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YkNYh0xlurE

Next is a philosophical song ‘isi bhanti sansar kahani kahta jata hai’.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5_iV71BvF7k

‘Har dukh ka savera hai par sham nahin hai’ is sung by Geeta Dutt, invoking ‘bhagwaan’.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uZzJ4TD3rC4

Next is a beautiful song by Asha in the same vein.
‘duniya ka mandir chhod ke chale gaye bhagwan,
isi se rota hai insaan, kaun ansoo ponchhe,
aaj pujari aur daku ki rahi nahin pehchan,
ise se rota hai insaan, kaun ansoo ponchhe.’
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VdiqJMa81t8

And now there is this mujra song by Asha. This is one of those great songs which Asha sang, and which hardly got attention.
‘ankhon ankhon men jinse ishare hue,
unse baithe hain dil apna haare hue.’
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X09SAgd7iyY

85 Hans October 3, 2020 at 12:02 pm

In the same year 1955, his able assistant Ravi also composed music for a devotional film Prabhu Ki Maya, which had again Prem Adeeb as lead actor and Pandit Madhur and Saraswati Kumar Deepak as lyricists. In this film Ravi naturally used his guru’s voice to full advantage. He also used the mukhda ‘bhajman narayan narayan’ from Bhagwat Mahima for one of the songs

I remember hearing a pujari of a temple near our house with loudspeaker, ‘bhajman narayan narayan narayan’. The pujari used ‘narayan’ three times, but this song used it twice. I dont know whether the pujari was singing some traditional aarti or he was inspired with this song. But, I do remember that this song was heard a lot on radio. I am giving here links to the song from both the films.
Bhagwat Mahima
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HjnOdvWsT68
Prabhu Ki Maya
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qOhs-Dc5toQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wW6Dt3wzVak

HK had other songs, which were great too.
‘jab jab hota nash dharma ka’
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6DsxlldpFk

‘Gange tumhin karo uddhar’ a song with a recital alaap by HK.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0nFYdWoQGRE

‘Moh kar parda kaala hai, jagat makdi ka jaala hai’
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-l2y1D–wrU

86 N Venkataraman October 3, 2020 at 12:35 pm

Hansji @ 79,
Thank you for your response.
You have got a point on both the matters under discussion. I went by what Hemant Kumar told/wrote in his biography.

When I wrote ‘he had the habit of writing mukhdas for song’ it was in reference to his Bengali film songs. I also read it for the first time in his biography. I quote,

‘I have my own approach for getting the lyrics written for songs. For the majority of the songs I write the first line and the songwriter writes the rest of the song.’ (Translated from ‘Anandadhara-1975’: page 65)

A clarification- I should have written ‘the first line’ instead of ‘the mukhda’.

He also mentions two songs from ‘Harano Sur’ (1957) in this context. Gouriprasanna Majumdar was the lyricist. And Gouriprasanna Majumdar and Bimal Ghosh were his main songwriters then. And Hemanta’s relationship with Gouriprasanna Majumdar dates back to the beginning of their careers. One can always reject it as an exaggeration.

He also mentions about his approach to composing tunes.

‘I do not spend much time in composing tunes. I compose whatever tune(s) that naturally came to me at that moment. After 7/8 days, on listening, if the tune still appeals to me then I retain it, else I reject it. This method I had followed till date. But when it came to Hindi films I had taken up a lot of assignments. I, Ravi and Rizbert had to work day and night and we had no time to spare. We did not have the luxury to keep aside the tune(s) for 7/8 days for re-listening. (Translated from ‘Anandadhara-1975’: page 65-66)

Let me also quote what he said in reference to the language and lyrics,
‘I was also lagging behind in one more area, and that was the language. Though I was composing music for Hindi (film) songs, I did not have enough mastery over the language. If one is not able to get deep into the soul of the lyrics and language, how can one give life to the songs? Bengali is my mother tongue. Bengali language runs in my blood vessels. I have full control over the language. That is the reason I could appropriately nourish them (Bengali songs). But when it came to Hindi film songs I could not do justice to the lyrics penned by the songwriters. Had I made the effort to learn the language, the songwriter’s efforts would not have gone to waste. Today I am able to realize my folly, but then it did not occur to me. ‘(Translated from ‘Anandadhara-1975: page-66)

I would cite another instance. It was Hemant Kumar’s initial days in Bombay. When Hemant Kumar first composed a tune for a song for the film ‘Shart’, Mr. Mukherjee was not satisfied. Probably Sashadhar Mukherjee realized his difficulty. He assigned a lyricist who knew Bengali very well. The lyricist was Shamsul Huda Bihari. S H Bihari did his graduation at the Presidency College, Kolkata. It was in Kolkata that he developed an interest in sports and even played football for Mohun Bagan Club. According to Hemanta, S H Bihari spent hours with him and helped him a lot.

Hemant Kumar has explained at length in his biography in the context of paucity of work which forced him to enter production. He clearly states that he did not have work in hand and he could have got a few assignments if he had approached some of the producers/ directors. But out of self respect he could not approach them and ask for work.
But to buttress your point I may speculate that this was before ‘Bees Saal Baad’ and ‘Kohra’, after which he might have restricted his Hindi films for other producers. Since you have explained your point and concluded that it was natural that he would defend his decision in his biography, I think I should not hang on further on this point.

Thank you Hansji for frankly sharing your viewpoint.

87 ksbhatia October 3, 2020 at 1:32 pm

Hans ji , Venkatraman ji ;

I am enjoying the detailed comments of each one of yours as many of songs posted were new to me ; and hence got up dated.

Enjoyed Songs and Bhajans from Bhagwat Mahima and that reminds me of Hemant Kumar and Geeta Dutt songs and Bhajans from Raami Dhobhan. This movie had a number of such songs which are truly divine . The movie is pre 60s so I am posting one song as an example . The song touches Rabindra sangeet chords….

Geeta Dutt , Hemant : Sau baras par : Film – Rami Dhoban (1953)…Hiren Bose [MD]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p941fm4Otvw

As I said earlier some songs got missed boarding pre 60s bus ….such as…..

Geeta Dutt, Hemant Kumar : insaaf kahaan hai (1957) Tujhe doon main kya…..Robin Baneerji

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMOdteNlhGU

This song reminds me of lilts of songs of Police !!

88 N Venkataraman October 3, 2020 at 1:38 pm

Pradeepji @ 80,
AAG, 1967.
Ae Nari, issi liye hi duniya mein aayee tu,
Amrit aanchal se pilaye,
Aankhon se piye aansoo..
Asad Bhopali or Indivar; Usha Khanna.
Hemant Kumar’s only song with UK.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DbxOuBeCYwk&feature=youtu.be

The uploader of the song wrongly mentions the date of release as 31.12.1936.

The HFGK and the uloader of the link mention Asad Bhoplai as the lyricist and at another site Indeevar is credited as the song writer.

Pradeepji, thank you for sharing the links of the above song and the song from the unreleased film ‘Anjaane Log’ commercially released in 1988 (through WhatsApp). The uploader of the songs mentions that the song was recorded in the 70s. A wonderful addition. Here is the link to the song

Meri Tanhaiyon Ke,Razdaaron tum na so Jaana, film Anjane Log (unreleased), lyrics Dev Kohli/ Shamim Jaipuri, music J Jagdish
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lVXqczfB0L8

89 N Venkataraman October 3, 2020 at 2:06 pm

Bhatia @ 82, 87,
I am also enjoying the nice anecdotes and songs posted by you and others.
Dhitang Dhitang Bhole is one of those popular songs of Salil Chowdjury-Hemanta.

The fine duet ‘Sau Baras Par, Preetam aaye Ghar’ is based on a Bangla Kirtan Ang, another folk/traditional genre. Thanks for the posting.
It was a nice coincidence; Pradeepji’s mention of the song from the unreleased film ‘Anjane Log’, reminded me of the song ‘Tujhe doon main kya’ from another ureleased film ‘Insaaf Kahan Hai. Prompt come the posting from you. Telepathy?

Let me post another duet by the same pair from the same film. Both the songs were penned by Hasrat Jaipuri.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FQ1QGwCZp-c

90 N Venkataraman October 3, 2020 at 2:33 pm

Rajeshji @ 83,
Hemant Kumar singing for Shammi Kapoor is indeed unusual.
Do you remember Shamshad Begum singing for Shammi Kapoor in Bluff Master?

Hemant Kumar rendered a couple of wonderful songs (duets) for Sunil Dutt too.
Neend Na Mujhko Aaye, a duet with Lata Mangeshkar, film Post Box 999 (1958), lyrics P L Santoshi, music Kalyanji
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z0ylZMYJ1Uo

91 ksbhatia October 4, 2020 at 12:40 pm

N Venkataraman ji 89;

Song from Insaaf Kahan Hain – Hey Babu Hey Bandhu – (Unreleased) is a great leisure and pleasure one ….a sort of stress buster. Such is the voice of Hemant ji that lingers on your lips for long long time as good as aroma of fine Tea as you sip slowly enjoying taste of melody and tea together.

Incidentally that reminds me of another tilting melody of Ravi that comes close to this song….Asha in …Aab to baat ban chhuki baat baar chhuki , aab to paas ayee aa bhi jayiye …..from …Chirag Kahan Roshni Kahan . A Guru Chhela shade !!!

92 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty October 4, 2020 at 2:06 pm

Dr Rajesh ji, NV ji,

Shammi Kapoor and Vyjayanti Mala . .

Halke halke chalo saanware
Pyar ke mast rahon mein…

HK, Lata; Prem Dhawan; Salil Chowdhury.

TANGEWALI, 1955.

93 N Venkataraman October 4, 2020 at 5:18 pm

Hansji @ 84 & 85,

Thanks for posting some highly listenable songs composed by Hemant Kumar for Bhagawat Mahima (1954).

The songs from Prabhu Ki Maya (1955) were really great. Both the films had a good number of songs rendered by Hemanta Kumar and Asha Bhosle.

‘Gange tumhin karo uddhar’ was the best of the lot.

BTW ‘Har dukh ka savera hai par sham nahin hai’ is a duet by Hemant Kumar and Geeta Dutt.

I would like to share another song composed by Hemant Kumar for the film ‘Bees Saal Pehle’ (1972), sung by Lata Mangeshkar. Originally the tune was composed for the Bengali film ‘Mon Niye’ (1969). The Bengali version became a hit, whereas the Hindi version went unnoticed

Chale Jete Jete Din Bole Jai, lyrics Mukul Dutta
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bBeKem1L4Ak

Aaj Bhi Hamara Dil Ghabraye , lyrics Shamsul Huda Bihari
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=677G1TypCSM

94 N Venkataraman October 4, 2020 at 5:23 pm

Pradeepji @ 92,
Shammi Kapoor and Vyjayanti Mala . .
Halke halke chalo saanware
Pyar ke mast rahon mein…
HK, Lata; Prem Dhawan; Salil Chowdhury.
TANGEWALI, 1955.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ii4veh1u0cA

One more song lip-synced by Shammi Kapoor!
Thanks for posting the wonderful romantic duet.

95 Rahul Bhagwanrao Muli October 4, 2020 at 7:29 pm

Venkataraman ji
Hats off for an extensively researched write up. It is not merely a historical & statistical perspective of Hemant Kumar’s career but a passionate sketch of the artiste also. I have not yet read the section relating to his foray in Bengali film industry as I am totally unfamiliar about the same.
I am very late in posting my comments but will add the following :
1 I think much before Kishor Kumar and Mohammad Rafi , it was Hemant Kumar who helped Dev Anand in establishing his image of an iresistable lover ( ye raat ye chandani) and happy go lucky wanderlust ( Hai apna dil) . Though the songs of this combo can be counted on fingers , almost each song is iconic.
2 Both as a singer and a composer , Hemant Kumar rarely had the benefit of working with stars ( Dev is an exception) . Pradip Kumar and Vishwajeet though fairly successful never attained the star status.
3 Hemant Kumar remained undettered by string of failures and consequent financial troubles of hindi movies produced by him in 60s. He in fact continued to be active for a long period after that.This is in contrast to two legends with whom he had some association.
A single commercial failure had taken heavy toll of Guru Dutt and Shailendra.
3 Lataji famously said that His voice is like that of a sadhu. I think that this expression is more appropriate for Hemanta the person rather than his voice.
No doubt his voice is divine in philosophical and spiritual songs but how could a sadhu render : a song as sensuous as ye nayan dare dare, a song as playful as jara nazaro se and a song as pristine as chupa Lo yu dil me.
My picks for post 60 Hemanta
songs :
1 “Sadhu” voice in album titled Valmiki ( 1976)
https://youtu.be/VOerxdC-YgI
My swar lists this song as ardas.
2 aaj phir chand ki peshani se
A beautiful gazal penned by Gulzar
https://youtu.be/Jk2iOl-Q5Rg
3 And the “Sadhu” singing for “goldman”
in a film titled Haiwan
https://youtu.be/KsPDBjq-Q-M
One really is baffled to know that this is composed by Bhappi Lahiri.

96 Dr. Rajesh Deshpande October 4, 2020 at 9:12 pm

Venkataramanji@90

Yes! I remember Chali chali kaisi hawa ye chali.
Its not easy to forget the visual of Shammi Kapoor singing a qawwali in drag!!

Venkataramanji@94, Dr. Shetty@92

Tangawali does not start Vyjayantimala.

And the YT link provided @94 has the right audio song but the video clip is from Shammi – Vyjayantimala film College Girl 1960

This is the link for the College Girl song – pehla pehla pyar ka ishara

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_U_9-s-UpTI

97 Dr. Rajesh Deshpande October 4, 2020 at 11:42 pm

Looks like the second HK solo from Kohra 1964 was still awaiting to be posted.
A nice breezy road song, it has always been overshadowed by Ye nayan dare dare

Raah bani khud manzil
peechhe reh gayi mushkil saath jo aaye tum

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wB7QFnlRdm4

98 Shankar Ghosh October 5, 2020 at 12:14 am

Nice narration. Collection of facts and figures and it’s placing with the songs worth mentioning. Could have touched about the period he lived opposite Menoka cinema hall till his death in the context of his bondage with his wife as far as her contribution in his works. You have really done a wonderful job. Hats off.

99 Hans October 5, 2020 at 10:42 am

It is well known that HK’s favourite female singer was Lata Mangeshkar. I give here some songs of this combo from the movies Lagan-1955 and Anjaan-1956. Though these songs remained in the shadows of other famous songs, yet the quality of composition is great.

Common link for two songs from Lagan ‘mujhe najar se utar kar bhi’ and ‘le aaj teri yaad ki nishani bech di’.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ls-EqoV_05I

Ye duniya badi bewafa ho gayi
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U51W2bYUoZI

Sawan ki aayi hai bahaar
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A1HGGDtUqzA

Aa chhua chhu..khel kabaddi
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YBasjwqrbV0

Din chhup gaya nikle taare
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KEMeaSLkCNo

100 Hans October 5, 2020 at 10:50 am

Venkataramanji, @ 93

Thanks for the info about ‘har dukh ka savera hai’. I listened to its mukhda and first antara for the feel of the tune. HK comes in the end. HFGK also gives only the name of Geeta Dutt. If I had known, I would have kept it for Vaishnavji”s article.

The Lata song in Bees Saal Pehle seems to be more naturally sung, yet it is lesser known. That is the difference between a sea and a lake.

101 Dr Pradeep Kumar Shetty October 5, 2020 at 12:20 pm

Dr Rajesh ji,

Thank you for the correction.

How stupid of me!

102 ksbhatia October 5, 2020 at 2:27 pm

Hans ji @99;

What a collection of melodies !! Heard all the songs of Lagan-1955 and Anjaan-1956. Simply amazing compositions beautifully sung by Lata ji . What more simple lyrics by Rajindra Krishan takes songs to another heights. With such songs ….you either remember everything or you forget everything ! I am at loss how I missed these hidden gems all these years .

No matter…Good songs takes on more meaning as the years pass by .

103 S Joseph October 5, 2020 at 6:45 pm

Hemant Kumar as MD song…

‘ Aaj rona pada…’/ 1961 / GIRL FRIEND / Sahir Ludhyanvi / Hemant / Kishore

https://youtu.be/NuUznTscH_8

104 Hans October 5, 2020 at 7:40 pm

Bhatiaji,

Thanks for the nice words. I was sure you would like the songs. HK as singer has been celebrated by many, but my purpose was to highlight his compositions. He was much better as composer than what people think of. If he had used a bit of variety using Rafi more and giving a song here and a song there to Mukesh and Talat, his success rate would have been better. After the success of Anarkali and Nagin, principally on Lata’s vocals, there came many films where only she was the singer and they flopped. Variety has always been the bollywood mantra whether it was music or story.

I would now take up songs of Durgeshnandini. This film had great music, but has rarely been talked about. In this film Lata had 5 solos and Asha 2. Lata’s ‘kahan le chale ho bata do musafir’ is so well known. Her ‘mat maro shyam pichkari’ has been posted by AK on a couple of occasions. I would choose two of her remaining 3 and make it Lata vs Asha – 2 against 2 – as both of Asha numbers are great.

Chand nikalege jidhar hum na udhar dekhenge – Lata. The song is as good as ‘kahan le chale ho’.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c6u6DBxpU9g

Meri majbooriyon pe jahan chup raha – Lata.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cXwUxgml1vk

Kaise main aaun piya paas tumhare – Asha.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9PAfnMiYvpI

Raat andheri dar laage – Asha.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kg6RRNP0rUU

105 Hans October 6, 2020 at 12:05 pm

Now look at the variety of composition in Bandi -1957.

First Geeta in a peppy street dance song.
‘Gora badan mora umariya bali’
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AsKJAgloJ_g

Then Lata in a sad mood in ‘mere haal par na hanso chand taaro’.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tw7I2ekcBbc

Asha Bhosle’s saheli chhed-chhad before marriage.
‘kahe sharmaye gori din ye suhana hai’
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xr-MJaQvElE

And icing on the cake is this fun song by Manna Dey.
‘ek bade baap ki beti ko’
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1QZwGlnlKRs

106 Sujit Ghosal October 6, 2020 at 5:16 pm

Extraordinary work to remember an extraordinary human being. Hindi audience is a little unfortunate not to have him more. Bengali people are more fortunate. In times, I wonder was he a better composer or singer? His non-film songs were like heavenly renditions. These non-film songs were very typical of bengali music firmament (which bengali people had enjoyed, in times, may be much more than film music, having subtle differences in lyrics, composition and style of singing compared to film song. Here the people had more of freedom
and quite often had done very creative experiments with compositions. Many of very popular and outstanding singers and composers of these modern basic disc songs whom were not that chosen for films for many reasons. In fact Manna Dey had been a hot choice for bengali films only since late 60’s only. In fact, Salil Chowdhury’s may be more than 90% of bengali songs were non-film songs used to be called ‘basic disc songs’. Talat Mahmood had sung most of his bengali songs in the ’40s and all in the ’50 and 60’s . Hemanta Mukherjee was also a singer par excellence for Rabindra Sangeet which has a distinct style of rendition with a relatively rigid swaralipi or notations, which, in those days had to be approved by a music board at Shantiniketan . Very few have achieved (I think none else) this distinction of singing Rabindra Sangeet as well as modern songs and becoming equally immensely popular and revered.
But still I would say Bengal could not also do justice to this colossal man when we did not see many programmes during his birth centenary. Frankly speaking, I have not come across a single research work like yours here.
The translation of ‘Neel Akasher Neechay’ is very good but might have scope for further refinement in places. Further, probably Bengali cinema revival was not influenced by hindi cinema but by the huge social and political changes occurring due to the partition of Bengal. As a matter of fact, during that period Bombay films were still having some influence of New Theatre people of Kolkata.
Overall, yours has been a stupendous work with a lasting contribution for the music lovers! We are grateful to you for remembering such a personality with so much of hard work, love, passion and understanding!

107 AK October 6, 2020 at 9:57 pm

Mr Sujit Ghoshal,
Welcome to Songs of Yore.

108 ksbhatia October 7, 2020 at 2:00 pm

Hans ji @104;

Song ….kahan le chale ho bata do musafir’….stands out as ….Melody Perfected by fine tuning and fine singing . Yes, Anarkali, Nagin and Durgeshnandini is a trio of Hemant Kumar’s ….bringing out the best of his compositions.

Among the songs listed ….Chand nikalege jidhar hum na udhar dekhenge….is a sure shot hit ….emotion unfurled and impeccably orchestrated . For me Lata’s songs stands better than Asha ji’s songs. Cinematic-ally 4th song is typically an escapist scene where dancers sings to please sipahyias enabling hero heroine to escape.

109 ksbhatia October 7, 2020 at 2:53 pm

Hans ji @105;

I am too glad to hear the sad song by Lata ji….. ‘mere haal par na hanso chand taaro’. Not only the perfect composition as also lyrics by Prem dhawan …simple and meaningful highlighting the emotion ….to which Lata ji responded with soul touching rendition. The effect of music is so….. very much more powerful and penetrating ….and lingers for long. For me a single song is enough to make my day. Thanks for sharing this beauty of Hemant ji’s creation.

Movie Bandi was directed by Satyan Bose that starred trio of Ganguly family and satyan repeated this cast in ….chalti ka naam gaadi . I wonder how successful was he directing the comedy and serious film Jagriti with midas touch !

110 ksbhatia October 7, 2020 at 4:13 pm

Venkatraman ji, Hans ji;

I feel I am related to the earliest times….stronger than the modern times . I wish I could see music being composed over the various instruments taking turn to play as a ballet or over a waltz….my favorite ! Todays machines have killed those delicately polished instruments , the ones that once played stayed for ever.

Replaying the past memories….here are some songs that should be daylighted…..

YEH SONE KI DUNIYA (1960) Hemant Kumar Lyric Bharat Vyas Music S. Mohinder Film Do Dost

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PXN-UBAgFz8

Tumhari Mohabbat Hai Ek Cheez….Hemant , Asha…Sahil.[1959]…Suresh Talwar.

This one is shammi kapoor starrer and probably lip cynicing Hemant kumar .

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M0zM8jrByv8

….to be contd.

111 ksbhatia October 7, 2020 at 4:25 pm

Venkatraman ji, Hans ji;

Two songs that missed the Bus….

Yeh Duniya Ek Sagar Hai – Hemant Kumar – BANDISH – Hemant Kumar….

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zJbUR2PVZ84&t=55s

mujhko dhundne wale tere dil me basa hua hu me..Hemant Kumar_

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gMWYDquMbcM

….to be contd.

112 ksbhatia October 10, 2020 at 4:20 pm

Venkatraman ji, Hans ji;

Of all the movies for which Hemant da gave music….I think the least represented has been Sahara [1958] . Hemant had only one song to be shared with chorus….and chorus dominated by Sudha Malohtra …my personal observation subject to scrutiny. The film had plenty of good numbers of beautiful songs sung by Lata ji . But the real charm of a mujraa song is by Sudha Malohtra . A beautiful song with finely crafted composition and complemented by easy soft lyrics by Bharat Vyas . I really enjoyed Tabla, ghoongroo and sarangi interludes. { Don’t blame me if you are reminded of same instruments in….apne kiye pe koi pesceman ho gaya }.

Mujhe Tarke Talluk Ke Liye | Sahara (1958) …Sudha Malohtra

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=byFCzqpSO_c

Now Hemant Kumar song ….

Har Dukhra Sehne Wali | Sahara (1958)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BEFIeQ7eTXA

Among 7 or 8 Lata ji’s songs , the one that stands best is….

Rut Aaye Rut Jaye…..Lata ji….

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oQbIIIMwTOY

113 N Venkataraman October 13, 2020 at 8:00 pm

Rahulji @ 95,
Sorry for the delay in responding. I was away on my first tour after the onset of Covid Pandemic.

True, Hemant Kumar rendered some great songs for Dev Anand (in all 18) and most of them were S D Burman’s compositions.

I think the album ‘Valmiki’ Wa (LP) was recorded in London. The complete rendition is available in YT.

The link to the song ‘Aaj Phir Chand Ki Peshani Se’ seems be from the later rerecorded version. Originally two records containing 4 songs penned by Gulzar and rendered by Hemant Kumar were released in 1967.

The song composed by Bappi Lahiri for Hemant Kumar is a pleasant surprise. Hemant Kumar also rendered two Bengali NFSs for his father Aparesh Lahiri.

Thanks a lot Rahulji for your nice words, observations and the songs.

114 Giri October 20, 2020 at 6:54 pm

Venkatraman ji,
An excellent post. I have come very late. But I went through the somewhat longish but absorbing post and all the comments. The two Hemantyan articles along with those of Vaishnav ji have covered almost all the works of Hemanth Kumar both as a singer and as a composer. You have brought out the life of Hemanth da in detail including his struggles, his love for the performing arts, his relationship with others in the field, his care for his own and his extended families etc. Your articles can be used as reference material on Hemanth Kumar.
You must have spent a lot of time in collecting the details and translation etc. The efforts have benefited persons like me who knew HK only as a composer and singer and nothing more.
Thank you for all the efforts.

115 D P Rangan October 26, 2020 at 2:19 pm

Venkataramanji
Deprivation of internet for nearly six months thanks to lackadaisical attitude of people at the helm of MTNL, had led to immense delay in responding to this admirable post of yours. It exhibits the great erudition you possess in anything you attempt. Your exposure to Bengali music, film and non film is unique and you alone could have written a post of this nature as you possess the required bailiwick. I enjoyed all the songs you posted as also by fellow commentators. To sum up your post is avant garde.

116 Ashwin Bhandarkar November 10, 2020 at 4:48 pm

Venkataramanji,

Belated congratulations on this superlative follow-up to the first part of Hemantayan! The wealth of detail, as also your deep knowledge of Hindi and Bengali cinema history, truly boggle the mind!! I am 200% sure that such an authoritative biography of Hemant Kumar has not been written before. Listening to the Bengali originals of two of my favourite songs – ‘O beqarar-e-dil’ and ‘Ek baar zara phir keh do’ – was a pleasure!

Thanks a ton for ‘Hemantayan’, a fitting tribute to the master in his centenary year!

117 S Joseph November 16, 2020 at 3:31 pm

With around 10,500 words ( approx. 6,000 words are for the Bengali films section and approx. 4,000 words are for the Hindi films section) , Hemantayan part 2 perhaps holds the record for the number of words at SOY for any single post. The two posts together total over 18,000 words. There is also a carefully selected collection of 31 songs in part 2 .

Hemant Kumar was fully devoted to music but it may remain a mystery why he refused the Padma awards when he had been accepting other awards.

Data on his contribution as a singer , as an MD and as a movie producer has been brought out well . We can know the number of Hindi movie songs remaining to be covered here. Such data has also given scope for analysis based on data .

Perhaps he was the only MD who must have travelled so frequently between 2 cities on work .

And with so much additional information from the learned readers , I am satisfied that I need not look elsewhere on this great man .

118 AK November 16, 2020 at 9:25 pm

Mr Joseph,
I ditto you. Venkataramanji’s two-part article is a monumental contribution and these contain goldmine of information. In tandem, Ashokji’s companion articles make this series of Centenary tributes a comprehensive work.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: