(Note: Dear Readers,
I believe some registered readers have not been getting email notifications about new posts on SOY. I request all the readers to register themselves again by entering their email in the bottom box captioned “Get mail updates”. You will get a notification from ‘Follow.it’ for confirmation. Please confirm the link, and you will start getting email notifications from future posts.
AK)
I understand most people on SOY know that Saraswati Devi was technically not the first female music director of Hindi film music. As per the current knowledge, two women preceded her – Ishrat Sultana (the singer Bibbo) was the first who composed music for the film Adal-e-Jahangir (1934) and the second was Jaddanbai who gave music for Talaash-e-Haque (1935) in which she also introduced her daughter, the famous Nargis, as a child artiste under the name Baby Rani. Saraswati Devi was really the third with her debut film Jawani Ki Hawa (1935) under the banner of the famed studio, the Bombay Talkies.
But if we have to anoint someone as The First Lady, how many of us can name any song composed by Ishrat Sultana or Jaddanbai? I can’t, and I guess hardly anyone can (A site states that no commercial records of their songs were made). In the men’s world of film music, Saraswati Devi was the First Lady to break the glass ceiling, to be remembered till today for her songs for the Bombay Talkies films like Achhut Kanya, Jeevan Naiya, Bandhan, Kangan, Jhoola etc. This was the era of the New Theatres in Calcutta, which had stalwarts like KL Saigal, Pankaj Mullick, KC Dey, Pahadi Sanyal and Kanan Devi. And what was the material she had at her disposal? Ashok Kumar, Devika Rani and Leela Chitnis. Getting known non-singers to sing songs that are remembered till today is an amazing feat.
Born Khorshed Maneksha Minocher-Homji in an affluent Parsi family in 1912, she had love for music from childhood. She got training in classical music under the renowned scholar, Vishnu Narayan Bhatkhande. Later she joined Marris College, Lucknow, which was the nursery of many budding talents, and is now known as Bhatkhande University of Music.
In the late 1920s she and her younger sister Manek Homji hosted a popular music programme at the recently-established All India Radio, Bombay. The programme was known as Homji Sisters’ Orchestra. There are several versions of how the sisters got into the Bombay Talkies. One version has it that Himanshu Rai was impressed by Khorshed Minocher-Homji at a music conference in Lucknow and he instantly invited her to come to Bombay and join his Studio in the music department. Another version credits Harendranath Chattopadhyay with introducing her to Himanshu Rai. To cut a long story short, the sisters joined the Bombay Talkies, recently established by Himanshu Rai and his wife Devika Rani, in around 1934.
In the studio era, as a paid employee in the music department, she did more than just composing music. She also looked after orchestra, instrument players, recording and training the actors to sing etc. In her team of musicians was also SN Tripathi who acted in some films, assisted her in music, later himself becoming an independent music director.
Bombay Talkies had a number of eminent Parsis as Directors. Two Parsi girls from ‘decent’ families working in the dirty world of Hindi films caused uproar in the conservative Parsi community. Himanshu Rai gave them new names: Saraswati Devi for the elder sister Khorshed Minocher-Homji, and Chandraprbha for the younger sister Manek. This provided some fig-leaf, but what would have mattered must be the success of the sisters, and the realisation that it would be improper to associate indecency with the Bombay Talkies as both Himanshu Rai and Devika Rani were highly educated from Europe and happened to come from families with high pedigree.
Her debut film was Jawani Ki Hawa (1935). Shooting for their next film, Jeevan Naiya was under way when Devika Rani eloped with the film’s hero Najmal Hussain, causing a big scandal. She was persuaded to come back, but the doors of the Bombay Talkies were shut on Najmal Hussain. A replacement had to be found. And a lanky lab assistant Kumudlal Kanjilal Ganguly was asked to act in the film opposite Devika Rani. He was given the screen name Ashok Kumar. Many had doubts about this man “with tremendous jaws” succeeding as a hero. But Ashok Kumar-Devika Rani pair became wildly popular from Achhut Kanya (1936) onwards.
The Second World War starting in 1939 and Himanshu Rai’s sudden death in 1940 brought turmoil in the Bombay Talkies. Its German director, photographer and other technicians were interned in jail. The Studio passed through some internecine conflicts. Devika Rani remained the titular boss, but she created two production teams, one headed by Amiya Chakravarty; the other by Rai Bahadur Chunnilal and Sashadhar Mukherjee which finally broke apart and formed the Filmistan Studios, but not before giving a spectacular hit Kismet (1943) for the Bombay Talkies, composed by Anil Biwas. Saraswati Devi’s own last films for the studio were Jhoola and Naya Sansar (1941). Kishore Kumar, the young brother of Ashok Kumar and Madan Mohan, the son of Rai Bahadur Chunnilal used to hang around the studio; Saraswati Devi gave an opportunity to them to join in chorus.
After the end of her association with the Bombay Talkies, she was invited by Minerva Movietone’s Sohrab Modi to compose music for his films Bhakt Raidas, Prarthana and Prithvi Ballabh (1943), but her simple style did not match with Minerva’s grand spectacles. She also composed as a freelancer for outside films, such as Amrapali (1945), Khandani (1947) and Usha Haran (1949), in which she also used Lata Mangeshkar. But the best of Saraswati Devi was over. Film offers declined, her last was the film Inaam (1955) in which SN Tripathi composed 6 songs, and she got only one.
I came across a most amazing information while researching for this post that in the 1950s when her film assignments had dwindled she composed the two iconic ghazals Lagta nahin hai jee mera ujade dayar mein (Bhadur Shah Zafar) and Ye na thi hamari kismet ki visaal-e-yaar hota (Ghalib) sung by Habib Wali Mohammad. I found it odd, because almost all sites on Sarswati Devi mention it, but no other site mentions this connection.
Disappointed by the changing trends of film music, Saraswati Devi started teaching music to children. The sisters remained spinsters and lived in obscurity. Saraswati Devi had an unfortunate accident in getting down from a bus fracturing her hips. She passed away on the 10th August 1980 in penury and solitude, ignored by Bollywood. Sad end to a great talent of the vintage era who was an integral part of the Bombay Talkies.
I pay my tributes to her with some songs we are all familiar with.
1. Koi humdum na raha koi sahara na raha by Ashok Kumar from Jeevan Naiya (1936), lyrics JS Kashyap ‘Naatwan’, music Saraswati Devi
Saraswati Devi gave the accidental hero to sing in his debut film Koi humdum na raha koi sahara na raha. A difficult song which his youngest brother Kishore Kumar reprised in his voice 25 years later in the film Jhumroo (1961). And another important trivia – SN Tripathi acted as a villain in the film and sang his first song.
2. Main ban ki chidiya ban ke ban ban dolun re by Ashok Kumar and Devika Rani from Achhut Kanya (1936), lyrics JS Kashyap ‘Naatwan’, music Saraswati Devi
Achhut Kanya with the story of love between a Brahmin boy and an untouchable girl was far ahead of its times. The film became a roaring success on the back of music by Saraswati Devi. Here is the duet sung by the two non-singers which was on everyone’s lips.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ABth5XKNoyE
3. Kit gaye ho khevanhaar naiya doobti by Saraswati Devi from Achhut Kanya (1936), lyrics JS Kashyap ‘Naatwan’, music Saraswati Devi
All the songs of Achhut Kanya were gems. I have earlier used the terrific dance song Chudiyan laya anmol re in the post on Mumtaz Ali. Here is a different song sung by Saraswati Devi herself for her sister Chandraprabha. Some sites mention this song as the start of playback in Bombay, though it is commonly acknowledged that playback started in Bombay with the film Mahageet (1937), composed by Anil Biswas. There is no dispute that the first person to discover and use playback was RC Boral in Calcutta in the film Dhoop Chhaon (1935).
4. Jai jai janmbhoomi pyari mata by Saraswati Devi (?) from Janmabhoomi (1936), lyrics JS Kashyap ‘Naatwan’, music Saraswati Devi
This patriotic song, picturised for a Dandi March-type scene during the Independence Movement created a lot of stir those days.
5. Piya aavan kah gaye na aaye, man nahin dharta dheer by Mumtaz Ali and Sunita Devi from Izzat (1937), lyrics JS Kashyap ‘Naatwan’, music Saraswati Devi
Mumtaz Ali was a common feature in many Bombay Talkies films. We know him better as the father of Mehmood and Minoo Mumtaz. He was a terrific dancer. This dance song is beautifully composed. Mumtaz Ali and Sunita Devi are the singer-dancers in the film. There is also a third woman whom I don’t know.
6. Nai naveli chali akeli maalaniyan albeli by Mumtaz Ali and Sunita Devi from Prem Kahani (1937), lyrics JS Kashyap ‘Naatwan’
Mumtaz Ali was an important element as choreographer-dancer-singer in many Bombay Talkies films. In many dance songs Sunita Devi or other women came first on the screen and Mumtaz Ali would join later. This is another beautiful song; Mumtaz Ali as the dancer in formal suit is a novelty.
7. Jhuki ayi re badariya saawan ki by Renuka Devi from Bhabhi (1938), lyrics JS Kashyap ‘Naatwan’, music Saraswati Devi
P Jairaj and Renuka Devi (real name Khursheed Mirza) were the lead actors in the film. Renuka Devi sings an immortal Meera bhajan in the film.
8. Jogan bhatak rahi hai ban ban wa ko paane by Leela Chitnis from Kangan (1939), lyrics Narottam Vyas, music Saraswati Devi
From Kangan onwards Leela Chitnis started acting opposite Ashok Kumar in Bombay Talkies films. Some songs were composed by Ramchandra Pal in this film. Pradeep Kumar debuted as a lyricist with this film and also sang a couple of songs. Videos of some songs are available, but their audio quality is very poor. I find this song in the voice of Leela Chitnis quite melodious.
9. Kaise chhipoge kaise chhipoge, O salone saajna ab kaise chhipoge by Leela Chitnis from Bandhan (1940), lyrics Pradeep, music Saraswati Devi
Bandhan is now famous for its iconic marching song Chal chal re naujawan which was adopted nationwide by the freedom fighters during the Independence Movement. This song came in the movie several times in different combinations, some solo in the voice of Arun Kumar, some in the voice of Ashok Kumar/Suresh and chorus. But this was composed by Ramchandra Pal. Kaise chhipoge shows Saraswati Devi’s mastery over composing simple, but catchy tunes in the voices of non-singer actors.
10. Piyu piyu bol piyu piyu bol praan papeehe piyu piyu bol by Pradeep from Bandhan (1940), lyrics Pradeep, music Saraswati Devi
Leela Chitnis is wating for her lover Ashok Kumar when an itinerant singer passes by singing this song, which brings tears to his eyes. Pradeep later became famous for his full-throated patriotic, devotional or message songs. In one of his best early songs, he is very soft and melodious. A wonderful composition by Saraswati Devi.
11. Ek chatur naar kar kar singaar by Ashok Kumar from Jhoola (1941), lyrics Pradeep, music Saraswati Devi
Now we come to the movie, starring Ashok Kumar and Leela Chitnis, which became the biggest blockbuster of the year. Its superhit songs in the voice of Ashok Kumar and Leela Chitnis must have had a major role in its success. Here is the original Ek chatur naar in the voice of Ashok Kumar which was reprised by RD Burman in Padosan (1968), sung by Kishore Kumar and Manna Dey/Mehmood. You can notice a novelty in the composition, credit for which should also go to the ‘natural’ actor Ashok Kumar. When he goes to take bath, his voice starts shivering in the cold.
12. Na jaane kidhar aaj meri naav chali re by Ashok Kumar from Jhoola (1941), lyrics Pradeep, music Saraswati Devi
This is another example of simple, catchy tunes which became immortal.
13. Kaahe neha lagaye sajaniya by Jahanara Kajjan from Prarthana (1943), lyrics Dr, Safdar ‘Aah’, music Saraswati Devi
Saraswati Devi’s association with the Bombay Talkies had come to an end after Jhoola and Naya Sansar (1941). For her songs from Prarthana (1943) under the banner of Minerva Movietone, starring Motilal and Sabita Devi, I especially like this thumri in the voce of Jahanara Kajjan.
14. Ye na thi hamari kismet ki visaal-e-yaar hota by Habib Wali Mohammad (Ghalib’s ghazal), music by Saraswati Devi (?)
Saraswati Devi composed music for some more films under different banners, including Usha Haran (1949) which had songs by Lata Mangeshkar and Rajkumari, but none that would set your heart aflutter. Here is this famous ghazal by Habib Wali Mohammad, which among many versions by different singers is my top favourite. I have added a question mark against Saraswati Devi, because this is the first time I am hearing this connection. But this is also mentioned by a knowledgeable person Kamalakar Pasupuleti, therefore, I am posting it here as an important contribution by Saraswati Devi.
15. Tu hi maare tu hi taare, tu hi bigadi baat sanwaare by Rajkumari, Mohantara Ajinkya (née Talpade?) from Inaam (1955), lyrics Narendra Sharma, music Saraswati Devi
For those interested in data, Tu hi maare tu hi taare should be the last film song composed by Saraswati Devi. This was the only song by her, the remaining 6 songs were composed by her once-assistant SN Tripathi.
Acknowledgements
The YT links of songs have been embedded only for the listening pleasure of the music lovers. This blog claims no copyright over the songs, which belongs to the respective owners.
{ 15 comments… read them below or add one }
She , indeed, was the First Lady of Music. The range of songs she composed was awesome.
Hari base sakal sansara..
Ashok Kumar.
ACHOOT KANYA, 1936
One of the first lullabies in our movies:
Bane Chandni ka palna
Jhoole Chand sa lalna..
Devika Rani.
JEEVAN PRABHAT, 1937
Chane zor garam..
Aroon Kumar.
BANDHAN, 1940.
Main toh Dilli se dulhan laya re..
Aroon Kumar, Rehmat Banu.
JHOOLA, 1941
Is duniya ki pagdandi mein
Tumhi ho mere sathi..
Amirbai Karnataki.
AMRAPALI, 1945.
AK ji,
Thanks for writing on Saraswati Devi. Not many people have written about her. Though she was the 3rd Woman Music Director , technically, effectively, she was the most prolific among the first 3 of her tribe.
This makes her actually the real First lady of Music in Hindi films.
BIBBO aka Ishrat Sultana has the distinction of being India’s(or rather the world’s) FIRST Woman Music Director, when she gave music to the film “ADL E JAHANGIR”-1934(it was also titled as NYAYEE- means one who does justice).There were 14 songs in the film .Later in 1937,she gave Music to yet another film, this time along with Dr.Samad, “QAZZAK KI BETI”. There were 9 songs in this film. She, however, did not become a professional or a prolific Composer-like Jaddanbai or Saraswati Devi.
Jaddanbai was an actor,singer, director and she also gave music to few films. Thus she became the second female music Director(after Bibbo) in India. As a Music Director,her films were-Talash e huq-35, Madame fashion-36, Hriday Manthan-36, Moti ka Haar-37 and Jeewan Swapna-37. She also sang 19 songs in 4 films.
The third and the most prolific Music Director till then, was Saraswati Devi. She sang 10 songs in 6 films and composed 262 songs in 31 films.
-AD
AK ji,
Thanks for writing on Saraswati Devi. Not many people have written on her. Though technically she was the third woman MD, she was the First Prolific woman MD of that time. She handled successfully the daunting task of getting Non Singers give Hit songs of that era. Her contribution to the success of Bombay Talkies films was noteworthy. Here is how the first 3 woman MDs performed…
BIBBO aka Ishrat Sultana has the distinction of being India’s(or rather the world’s) FIRST Woman Music Director, when she gave music to the film “ADL E JAHANGIR”-1934(it was also titled as NYAYEE- means one who does justice).There were 14 songs in the film .Later in 1937,she gave Music to yet another film, this time along with Dr.Samad, “QAZZAK KI BETI”. There were 9 songs in this film. She, however, did not become a professional or a prolific Composer-like Jaddanbai or Saraswati Devi.
Jaddanbai was an actor,singer, director and she also gave music to few films. Thus she became the second female music Director(after Bibbo) in India. As a Music Director,her films were-Talash e huq-35, Madame fashion-36, Hriday Manthan-36, Moti ka Haar-37 and Jeewan Swapna-37. She also sang 19 songs in 4 films.
The third and the most prolific Woman Music Director till then, was Saraswati Devi. She sang 10 songs in 6 films and composed 262 songs in 31 films.
-AD
Dr Shetty,
You have added some rare songs. Thanks a lot.
Arunji,
Thanks a lot for giving detailed information on the first three lady music directors.
A great write up that is not only enlightening but again showed me how little I know about Hindi films and music. This piece has also touched upon so many interesting historical facts of the Hindi film world.
Certainly she was great personality of HFM.
The closing of this beautiful tribute was painful . ‘….She passed away on the 10th August 1980 in penury and solitude, ignored by Bollywood….’ Sad . It reminds us that this world is very cruel.
But we are all responsible for her condition as we all developed a taste for ‘ golden era ‘ HFM . Or was it the tsunami of the ‘golden era’ MDs… SJ, Naushad , CR, SDB, Salil Choudhary, Madan Mohan and such others , that also ended the HFM careers of so many other greats like Pankaj Malik , KC Dey , RC Boral , Anil Biswas… ?
Mr Joseph,
Thanks a lot. For successful film personalities to die in penury is always tragic. Saraswati Devi was top of the tops during Bombay Talkies heydays. Golden Era was characterised by easy tunes, super-talented composers and great playback singers. This might have meant end of some careers, but all the greats did not face such financial distress. There are many factors for that.
Thank you for a very enlightening article, AK. This was very informative and interesting.
Madhu,
Thanks a lot for your appreciation.
AKji, Thanks for this wonderful piece on Saraswati Devi! It was while researching for a post that I came across her name. The fact that her tunes were reprised in many a movie goes to show how wonderful they were.
One still feels that music direction and song writing was a male preserve in the golden era though it is now that there is a young lot that is into music direction and song writing.
The other name that comes to mind is that of Usha Khanna. I heard an interview of hers on Vividh Bharati where she says that many used to feel that her tunes were actually made by a male music director and she merely put her name on them. That was how biased some were. Usha Khanna was trained in classical music. Just listen to this raagmalika from the movie Sweekar Kiya Maine.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FE5oVGDjwZE
Anita,
You are welcome. Usha Khanna was the lone woman music director in the Golden Era like Saraswati Devi in the Vintage Era, who made a mark. Doubting that Usha Khanna’s tune were not hers is most unfair to her, and I dare say completely off the mark. Her debut score in the film Dil De Ke Dekho (1959) was consciously a copy of OP Nayyar style, perhaps at the behest of its director Nasir Hussain, who tasted great success with OPN in Tumsa Nahin Dekha (1957). But when there was no such demand her, she gave music for many singers in many different styles. The classical song you have added is quite nice. Thanks.
AK Ji,
Great to know about the first ( for all practical purpose) lady music director, Sarswati Devi. Although personally I can not relate to most of the songs of the vintage era, they definitely set the path for others to follow. Their achievements with very primitive technology is really great.
I find Usha Khanna not being represented in SOY ..may be it is time to have a blog on her. Some of her songs are too good and should easily be considered equal in quality to her illustrious contemporaries.
Mr Sivanandam,
Thanks. I think in this rarefied film Usha Khanna comes next. Her songs are too good. It is sad that she was not counted in the top bracket.
AKji,
I was planning a post on Saraswati Devi this year on her death anniversary, which I couldn’t actually complete. You have beaten me to it.
I enjoyed the songs. It’s really commendable that she could compose memorable songs even with non singers. That says it all.
Mumtaz Ali dancing in a formal suit was really a surprise.
Now I am planning the post next year.
Anup
🙂
Anup,
You would surely do an exhaustive job in your tribute. Mumtaz Ali’s dancing was mostly folk/kathak. Dance in formal suit is really unique.